Low fertility in East Asian economies: examining the role of social norms and childcare investment
Over the past three decades, most economically developed East Asian countries have witnessed a drop in fertility levels.1 In fact, the decline of these rates has been so fast that governments have started to take note of their impact on labour supply and shortages. This has become even more problematic in light of the growing proportion of senior citizens with increasing life expectancies.2 Cultural norms like Confucianism and patriarchal family traditions have played a key role in the pressure placed on East Asian women to fill in roles as caretakers—not only for the elderly but also for children—rather than relying on a public or formally instituted system.3 Low government investment in childcare is another contributing factor.
The role of culture and social norms
Culturally, childcare is viewed as an informal, unpaid task provided by mothers rather than a service provided by the state. This overburdens women, who are often juggling a paid job and household responsibilities. In South Korea, for example, the responsibility of taking care of children falls on mothers—this expectation, driven by social norms and coupled with a lack of public childcare facilities that come at a high cost, burdens women as caretakers while reducing their options for work.4
In addition, following the 1997 Asian financial crisis, a widespread social norm of women’s employment arose.5 This means that the extreme balancing act of juggling a paid job and unpaid domestic work—which is also expected of women6—while potentially raising children has affected the fertility rate. Studies have shown that the likelihood of couples having a second child is higher if husbands spend more time on childcare and household chores.7
The need for government investment
Another factor is the lack of government investment in childcare. There is often a blurred distinction between private education and formal childcare. In many East Asian countries, parents invest heavily in their children’s education from an early age. And as competitiveness steadily increases, and this education begins earlier, high-cost private education often takes prominence over childcare.8 This also underscores an affordability concern—even economies with regulatory frameworks around the public provision of childcare, such as China, Vietnam and Thailand, do not mandate free provision.9
In other countries like Japan, the government’s lack of support for larger nurseries in cities means that unauthorised and unsubsidised nurseries are forced to charge higher fees from parents to cover their operational costs. Parents seeking babysitters often find themselves unable to secure help, in part due to tight immigration policies.10 China, South Korea and Hong Kong all experience more demand for childcare than the number of available openings.11
Necessary shifts
Research has found that in East and South-east Asia, more comprehensive family policies that shift away from patriarchal norms indicate the government’s concern about the factors impacting fertility levels and may offer a more productive step forward.12 Transforming social policies alone, such as parental leave and childcare reform, will not be sufficient. Workplace culture must also adapt to provide parents with a more sustainable range of options alongside government investment in childcare service provision overall.13
References
- 1Sobotka, Tomás. "World’s highest childlessness levels in East Asia", Population & Societies, vol. 595, no. 11, 2021, pp. 1-4.:
- 2 McDonald, Peter. “Explanations of low fertility in East Asia: A comparative perspective,” in Ultra-Low Fertility in Pacific Asia, ed. Paulin Straughan, Angelique Chan, Gavin Jones (London: Routledge, 2008), 25.:
- 3Kim, Erin Hye-Won. "Division of domestic labour and lowest-low fertility in South Korea." Demographic Research 37 (2017): 743-768.:
- 4 Anderson, Thomas, and Hans-Peter Kohler. "Education fever and the East Asian fertility puzzle: A case study of low fertility in South Korea." Asian population studies 9, no. 2 (2013): 196-215.:
- 5Eun K-S. Lowest-low fertility in the Republic of Korea: Causes, consequences and policy responses. Asia-Pacific Population Journal. 2007;22(2):51–72.:
- 6Jones G. United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division; New York: 2011. Recent fertility trends, policy responses and fertility prospects in low fertility countries of East and Southeast Asia. Expert paper no. 2011/5.:
- 7Kim, Erin Hye-Won. "Division of domestic labour and lowest-low fertility in South Korea." Demographic Research 37 (2017): 743-768.:
- 8Ibid:
- 9Women, Business and the Law. Toward available, affordable and quality childcare in East Asia and Pacific. World Bank, 2022.:
- 10Sugeno, Fumi. “Solving Japan’s Childcare Problem.” Stanford Social Innovation Review, 2017.:
- 11Tsuya, Noriko O. "Below-replacement fertility in Japan: Patterns, factors, and policy implications." Low and lower fertility: Variations across developed countries (2015): 87-106.:
- 12Tonelli, Simone, Sonja Drobnič, and Johannes Huinink. "Child‐related family policies in East and Southeast Asia: An intra‐regional comparison." International Journal of Social Welfare 30, no. 4 (2021): 385-395.:
- 13Jones, Gavin W. "Ultra-low fertility in East Asia: policy responses and challenges." Asian Population Studies 15, no. 2 (2019): 131-149.:
