Impact Economist Logo
4 children sitting eating food
4 children sitting eating food
Supported by

Developing comprehensive childcare policies: a roadmap for policymakers

The importance of childcare

The availability of childcare services is a crucial enabler of economic progress—allowing willing and able parents to participate in the workforce, contribute to family income and support national economic growth. Besides the benefits of promoting parental employment, enrolment in formal centre-based care services also provides young children with the opportunity to participate in early education. Research suggests that early education and care results in positive outcomes for children’s emotional and cognitive development, educational achievement and long-term success. Moreover, it has the potential to create strong positive human and financial impacts that stretch into adulthood. For instance, the Perry Project in the US found that preschool attendees were more likely to graduate from high school and earn more money. They were also less likely to be involved in criminal activity.1

The state of childcare

Childcare provision in most countries, however, remains fraught. There are several challenges such as uneven access, lack of affordable options, long waiting lists, lack of awareness, inadequate staff, inconvenient locations, unsuitable timings, uncertain quality and often a lack of supporting policies. Even among OECD members, laws on childcare provision vary significantly. A 2021 study by UNICEF examining childcare provision in a sample of rich countries noted that the best performers combined parental leave, affordability and quality of organised childcare.2 In terms of outcomes, rich countries with successful childcare provision were found to have high enrolment rates and fewer parents struggling with childcare costs.

What is a comprehensive childcare policy?

Comprehensive childcare policies are designed to best meet the needs of the population. Since the needs may look vastly different across individual countries, policymakers must work alongside the private sector to create a policy framework that is robust and flexible enough to accommodate the needs of a diverse population. This also requires a healthy dialogue with key stakeholders.

Childcare must be accessible, affordable and high-quality

For parents and caregivers to use childcare services, these services need to be accessible, defined as the ease with which parents and caregivers can access childcare services. This could depend on factors such as having sufficient spaces for enrolment, reasonable wait times, proximity of centres to workplaces, timings of operations and enough awareness among communities about the availability of these services. In the developing world, access often serves as the first obstacle, as a large part of the population does not have easy access to childcare infrastructure and benefits. Research suggests that in African countries like Côte d'Ivoire, Rwanda and Senegal, only 1% of children aged zero to two years are enrolled in formal early childhood care and education.3 Once there is access, attention moves to the affordability and quality of childcare.

Measuring access through the gross enrolment ratio for the pre-primary age group in 2019

Source: World Development Indicators, Economist Impact

Affordability refers to how expensive or economical it is for a parent to enrol their child in a childcare centre. Affordability can often also serve as a barrier to access, particularly for economically disadvantaged groups.

Quality is a broader term that encompasses aspects like health and safety provisions, educational curriculum and the availability of qualified and trained staff, quality of interactions and engagements. It is critical, though, that quality remains at the forefront of any policies and programme designs to ensure children’s development and learning. Quality is essential to ensure good outcomes for young children and as a “signal” to motivate parents to enrol their children in the first place. Parents may be unwilling to leave their children in facilities that do not feel safe or likely to benefit their children.4

Policy mix

The effectiveness of any childcare policy also depends on the choice of instruments used to execute the policy and the set of supporting policies. Standalone policies focusing only on the provision of childcare services are less likely to promote their uptake than a complete set of policies focusing on parental leave, breastfeeding support, employment protection and healthcare benefits, among other aspects. Policy targeting and distribution is another key factor that can determine the success of a childcare policy framework. For instance, providing a direct subsidy in the form of reduced fees for childcare centres is likely to promote higher uptake, as it enables both formal and informal sector employees to use these services, versus providing only in-work benefits that limit their use to formal sector employees.

Ensuring universal access to childcare is part of building a social infrastructure that has long-term economic and social benefits for society. The cost of inaction is too high for policymakers and decision-makers to ignore.

References
watercolor illustration of house
Back to home
Learn more
watercolor illustration of globe
Explore key findings
Explore more