Examining trends in maternal labour force participation with near universal access: the case of Australia, Germany and the UK
Women often bear a disproportionate share of caregiving responsibilities, resulting in lower labour force participation compared with men. This, in turn, leads to decreased household income, reduced consumer spending, lower tax revenue and, ultimately, substantial GDP losses. The enduring consequences on children, human capital development and a country’s overall productivity, are dire.
Recognising this, Economist Impact, supported by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, launched the childcare dividend initiative. It aims to underscore the urgent need for accessible, affordable and high-quality childcare by analysing social media data and estimating the short-term economic benefits of near universal childcare access in 15 countries.1 The study employed gross enrolment rates in pre-primary education to identify access gaps. For 12 out of 15 countries, we found that achieving 100% enrolment could empower an additional 10 million mothers to enter the labour force, contributing a cumulative US$1.2trn in GDP gains– equivalent to Indonesia's annual economic output.
Are the wealthiest nations neglecting comprehensive childcare for families?
The story differs slightly for three countries—Australia, Germany and the UK. These countries are a step ahead of others in our dataset and have achieved 100% enrolment in pre-primary education, but they lag in terms of affordability and quality versus their OECD peers. High enrolment rates in Australia, Germany and the UK contrast the relatively lower government spending on early care and education—falling short of the OECD’s average of 0.8% of GDP.2 Notably, the UK's contribution to childcare funding has shown a worrying decline over the past decade. This is in stark contrast to Iceland—a leader in childcare provision— that allocates ~2% of its GDP to early childcare services.3
The situation is particularly alarming in Australia and the UK when examining public expenditure on early childhood care and education on a per child basis. Taking pre-pandemic figures into consideration, the average expenditure by OECD countries stood at US$5,8004 per child (aged 0-5). Countries like Denmark, Iceland, Luxembourg, Norway and Sweden spend more than US$11,000 per child. However, Australia and the UK allocate merely US$4,500 and US$3,600 respectively.5 This substantial disparity may offer a plausible explanation for their underperformance in the affordability and quality dimensions, as revealed in the childcare index published by UNICEF in 2021.6 The absence of affordable and high-quality childcare in these nations directly impacts mothers, their economic participation and, inevitably, their national income.
Total public expenditure on early childhood education and care as a % of GDP, 2019 or latest available
Source: OECD
Revitalising maternal labour force participation through early care investment
Building on its initial model assessing the impact of accessible childcare on maternal labour force participation rates, Economist Impact formulated estimates to measure the effects of increased public spending on early care on maternal labour force participation. This model controls for other influencing factors such as the fertility rate, education level, unemployment rate and national output. For the three OECD countries studied, our findings indicate that a 1% uptick in public spending on early care can boost maternal labour force participation by 0.03%. Our research suggests that allocating up to 2% of GDP by 2030—akin to Iceland’s current childcare expenditure—could approximately introduce a million more working mothers in affluent nations. If Australia, Germany and the UK adopt this approach, it could usher 0.72 million additional mothers into the workforce, potentially revitalising the stagnant female labour force participation rates in these countries. The resulting economic benefits, through a domino effect, could be substantial.
The UK stands to experience the most significant surge in maternal labour force engagement—potentially adding 0.4 million mothers. Such a shift is paramount, especially amid a global economic downturn. Nations can ill afford to squander available economic resources. Tapping into maternal labour force engagement in the near term and reaping increased productivity from enhanced human capital development in the long run might offer countries a lifeline in an era forecasted to be rife with technology conflicts, unstable political structures, labour shortages and an ageing populace.
Maximising the return on investment
Childcare policies often operate independently, lacking alignment among regulatory bodies regarding ownership.7 Is it a labour market matter, a child development concern or a social issue? They are all of these things. To make the most of childcare investments, policies must align to guarantee accessible, affordable and quality care. This approach can promote economic growth in the short and long term, bridge the persistent gender gap, empower women and help mothers return to work and realise their potential.
References
- 1Australia, Brazil, Canada, Chile, Germany, India, Indonesia, Kenya, Mexico, Nigeria, South Africa, South Korea, the UK, the United States and Vietnam—accounting for nearly 48% of global GDP and 42% of the global population:
- 2OECD. “Pf3.1: Public spending on childcare and early education”. : https://www.oecd.org/els/soc/PF3_1_Public_spending_on_childcare_and_early_education.pdf
- 3Ibid:
- 4All figures in this paragraph are in purchasing power parity (PPP) terms:
- 5Ibid:
- 6Gromada, Anna, and Richardson, Dominic, 2021.”Where do rich countries stand on childcare?” UNICEF Office of Research – Innocenti, Florence. : https://www.unicef-irc.org/where-do-rich-countries-stand-on-childcare
- 7Devercelli, Amanda E.; Beaton-Day, Frances. 2020. “Better Jobs and Brighter Futures: Investing in Childcare to Build Human Capital”. World Bank, Washington, DC. : https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/entities/publication/385821d3-bce3-5640-b140-48e27b58296b
