
By Melanie Markwick-Day ACII
Renewable energy & alternative fuels practice Leader, Chubb Climate+ Overseas general division
The transition to a net-zero economy calls for decarbonisation across all sectors. In the power sector, this means moving away from the production and burning of fossil fuels—a major contributor to carbon emissions—and moving towards clean energy alternatives such as solar and wind.
↑ 34.4 GW
In 2010, global offshore wind capacity was just 3.1 gigawatts (GW). By 2020, it had grown to 34.4 GW, more than a tenfold increase.
Over the past two decades, as costs have fallen and technology has evolved, renewable energy capacity has skyrocketed. The World Resources Institute estimates that the cost of solar electricity has fallen by 85% since 2010, and the cost of both onshore and offshore wind electricity has halved. Offshore wind energy production has increased at an astonishing rate. In 2010, global offshore wind capacity was just 3.1 gigawatts (GW). By 2020, it had grown to 34.4 GW, more than a tenfold increase. And just three years later, it had nearly doubled to 68 GW—enough to power more than 47m homes for an entire year.
One way to maximise the many benefits of wind energy is meshed offshore grids. These are smaller, marine versions of the land-based grid: networks of offshore windfarms linked to one another by high-voltage direct current (HVDC) cables and capable of sharing power among themselves.
Meshed systems can provide an alternative path for energy delivery in the event of an outage or other disruptive event at any of the interconnected facilities. By allowing for the redirection of generated power, they can help to ease the grid congestion that leads to curtailment—the term for when clean energy producers must temporarily reduce their output so that grid operators can maintain an appropriate balance between energy supply and demand. Interconnectivity can also yield economic benefits for consumers by injecting more wind energy into markets where demand, and costs, tend to be higher.
Optimising offshore wind with HVDC
The typical offshore windfarm uses an array of high-voltage alternating current (HVAC) or HVDC cables to send its generated power to substations and, ultimately, the grid. This linear, point-to-point pathway is called a radial interconnection. Some of these windfarms are way out at sea, such as the under-construction Dogger Bank project, located more than 130km off the English coast. But the majority are much closer to shore, where HVAC cables are generally well suited for transmitting power.
They are less well suited, however, for transmitting power across greater distances. For every extra kilometre that an HVAC cable extends, slightly less energy reaches its final destination (a phenomenon known as “transmission loss”). Because of this, most HVAC lines extend no further than about 80km.


The meshed offshore grids currently envisaged in Europe and the United States would link windfarms that are hundreds of kilometres apart. Because HVDC cables have much lower rates of transmission loss, they are far better at carrying large amounts of power over long distances with maximum efficiency. So they are seen as an infrastructural requirement for any meshed offshore network.
Engineers, policymakers and energy analysts are bullish about the potential of HVDC-supported meshed offshore grids to bring more wind energy into the power sector globally. But all of them acknowledge that although speed is of the essence, the development of these clean energy resources must be approached with a full awareness of their complexities.
Unique challenges
Those complexities include the higher cost of installing and maintaining the HVDC infrastructure that is required to make meshed offshore grids viable—a cost that may not be feasible within emerging markets and developing economies. Although HVDC cables are more economical than their HVAC counterparts over long distances, the need for extra equipment such as terminal converter stations represents a significant upfront expenditure.
Further, “modernising” the grid means digitalising it. Although any newly created meshed offshore networks would reap the benefits that come with digitalisation (including improved demand response and increased capacity for energy storage), they would also be subject to the attendant risks, including cyberattack. And though physical attacks are uncommon, subsea cables are still vulnerable to damage inflicted intentionally by malicious actors. That risk is only likely to grow as the technology surrounding deep-sea exploration advances and it becomes easier to deploy autonomous or remotely piloted devices onto seabeds.


Most damage, however, is inflicted naturally or accidentally. Underwater earthquakes and landslides are not uncommon. And the phenomenon known as hydrodynamic scour, in which fast-flowing water carves into the seabed as it makes its way around objects, can dramatically alter undersea topography. Remotely operated vehicles (ROVs) that skitter across the ocean floor during undersea research operations may also present a risk, as well as fishing gear and anchors dropped from boats.
Other factors that may negatively impact the decision to invest include the volatile price of copper, which is the principal conductive material used in subsea interconnectors; the scarcity of cable-laying vessels (only about 40 ships worldwide are well suited to this task); supply-chain issues; and the difficulty of finding trained professionals with the skills necessary for HVDC installation and maintenance.
The way forward
How can we set the stage for meshed offshore grids? First, energy companies will need to find new and improved methods for manufacturing, transporting and laying undersea cables to minimise the risk of damage, as well as new ways to identify and locate cable faults to speed up repairs. More sophisticated systems for monitoring the activity of trawlers and other seagoing vessels, together with the development and enforcement of “early warning” protocols, will help to reduce the impact of damage to cables by anchor strike.
At the policy level, governments should work with windfarm operators, the fishing industry and other stakeholders to establish exclusion zones limiting vessel activity over and around cable siting. And we also need quicker, more streamlined permitting processes for meshed grids as bottlenecks are already a chief complaint of energy companies.
Around 80% of all insurance claims filed by offshore wind companies involve subsea cable failure, according to assurance and risk management provider DNV. The development of meshed offshore grids presents an opportunity to update and improve cable performance, and with it the performance of the entire offshore wind sector.
Doing so will mitigate risk in several ways. The meshed network model significantly reduces the risk of a single point of failure—a key vulnerability of the radial, point-to-point transmission model. By building resilience directly into the system through diversification of resources and assets, meshed offshore grids also mitigate the impact of transmission-threatening damage to wind infrastructure from extreme weather events. Greater efficiency will lower operating costs over time. All of these factors will increase the insurable value of wind projects and create the potential for lower premiums.
Insurers have a crucial role to play in these projects as both students and managers of risk—some of which will be new and unfamiliar. Chubb’s ability to meet this challenge is unsurpassed. Our diverse team of risk engineers includes clean energy specialists with a deep and comprehensive understanding of the offshore wind sector. In addition, we offer tailored insurance products across commercial lines designed to make windfarm owners and grid operators feel more secure as they work together to get us closer to our net-zero goals. With Chubb as their partner, they can get us there faster.