
Building government support for quality childcare
Nearly 30 years ago Quebec introduced a government-sponsored, low-cost childcare system. Between 1996 and 2016 Quebec’s labour participation rate of women whose youngest child was under three rose by nearly 20 percentage points, compared with just four in next-door Ontario, which does not have a similar government-supported childcare system.1 And the economic effects in the province extended beyond labour-force participation: in 2019 alone this investment in childcare contributed an additional C$7bn to the province’s GDP.2 Canada is now in the process of expanding universal childcare provision across the country. Quebec’s story is not unique. In Brazil, centre-based childcare raised the probability of maternal employment by 44 percentage points, increasing mothers’ work in the formal sector. Mexico experienced similar outcomes following its significant expansion of childcare in 2007.3 Despite many governments beginning to recognise the importance of affordable childcare—the G20, under South Africa’s presidency, included childcare in its 2025 Leader’s’ Declaration4—current efforts need to be scaled up. Lack of affordable childcare continues to be one of the biggest barriers to women’s opportunities to work. Following in the footsteps of governments who have invested in affordable childcare, however, requires a monumental shift in thought from viewing childcare as a burden on already overstretched social services to an investment in long-term economic growth and the labour market.

The African context
Over 40% of children globally—or nearly 350m—below primary-school-entry age need childcare but do not have access to it.5 Across Africa, the percentage is higher. In some African economies, only 1% of children under the age of two are enrolled in formal early childhood care and education, owing to inadequate infrastructure and limited government support.6 In Kenya just 0.28% of total education aid from Official Development Assistance (ODA) is allocated to early childhood education (ECE) and care, and the government directs just 0.08% of GDP towards ECE and care.7
This lack of childcare access is holding women’s labour-force participation back. Just under one-quarter of primary caregivers in Kenya—the bulk of whom are women—would plan to join or rejoin the labour force if affordable childcare services were available.8 Where women do have access to subsidised childcare, the impact is clear: they are 17% more likely to be employed and are less likely to lose earnings owing to care responsibilities.9
Jasmina Papa, a social protection specialist at the International Labour Organisation (ILO)
Jasmina Papa, a social protection specialist at the International Labour Organisation (ILO), said at a side event to the G20 in Johannesburg hosted by Economist Enterprise and supported by the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation that “28% of women [in Sub-Saharan Africa] say that care responsibilities are preventing them from labour-market participation. But the devil is in the details. Women in Sub-Saharan Africa often are in informal employment. So basically, they're performing two jobs: caring and working informally close to home and with flexible schedules so that they can earn and they can provide unpaid care. And this is for me one of the reasons why we should really more forcefully and decisively talk about women's contribution to the economy through paid informal work and through unpaid care.”
The consequences of employable mothers being unable to participate in the workforce—or forced into informal, flexible paid employment—are significant. According to Economist Enterprise’s Childcare Dividend Initiative, supported by the Gates Foundation, South Africa, Kenya and Nigeria lost US$5.1bn in employment income in 2022. And these losses affect economic growth: if Nigeria's 1.7m mothers entered the labour force over the next five years, they could drive almost 1.1% GDP growth through higher incomes and tax revenue.
Shifting the narrative
Across the region, ministries of gender and social services have been pushing action plans and policies that include childcare. For example, the government of Kenya is accelerating efforts to develop a comprehensive National Care Policy.10 But austerity measures across Africa over the past five years have slashed social services budgets. Public education and health services have suffered.11 Top of mind for those pushing for affordable childcare services is a critical question: how do we make the case to government budget holders that investing in childcare is not another social service that will burden public finances, but an investment opportunity that drives returns and economic growth?
Ilifa Labantwana is an early childhood development programme in South Africa founded in 2007. Originally established by grants from civil society partners, it focuses on providing tested, scalable, cost-effective childcare models to ensure marginalised communities and those affected by poverty have access to high-quality, affordable childcare.12 Unlike many other civil-society-driven childcare providers, Ilifa Labantwana has pursued partnerships with national government stakeholders, including, critically, the Department of the Treasury, the National Planning Commission and the Office of the Presidency. It has also worked with provincial governments to ensure coverage of those most in need.
Zaheera Mohamed, chief executive of Ilifa Labantwana
Zaheera Mohamed, chief executive of Ilifa Labantwana, explains how the organisation has been successful in shifting government perceptions of childcare from a social burden to an economic driver: “Firstly, it was changing the discourse about what early childhood development or childcare means. Talking about the importance from children's perspective, from a child- outcomes perspective, [through] the long-term benefits to the economy, but also bringing it home to show the immediate outcomes, the immediate job- creation opportunities, the immediate micro-enterprising opportunities that are there. So really making the economic case that we didn't really make before. And that's the language that our government and our treasuries understood.”
Ms Mohamed goes on to explain how her organisation needed to adjust how itthought about early childhood development and childcare. She hired a team of economists to ensure that Ilifa Labantwana understood the economics of childcare and could integrate its economic impact into how it discussed its programmes. She says, “The biggest success we've made is actually unlocking the government's public finances. The other discourse that we're working on shifting is that, because childcare is seen as care and as a social good, there's a tension around framing that as an enterprise opportunity. The concept of social enterprising is really hard for governments to get their head around. The next big phase of the work that we need to unlock is really starting to get micro-enterprise funding out, to recognise it [childcare] as an income- earning opportunity.”
Zaheera Mohamed, chief executive of Ilifa Labantwana
Ilifa Labantwana’s success in shifting the narrative around childcare to focus on the economic benefits helped to release public funding. Strengthening access to affordable, high-quality childcare is a strategic economic priority, not a luxury—it benefits families, communities and entire economies alike. Reframing the benefits in language that treasurers and national budget officers understand is critical to capturing currently elusive public funds, and has the possibility to shift responsibility for driving childcare provision from civil society to government, which is where it should lie.
Supported by the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation
The William and Flora Hewlett Foundation invests in creative thinkers and problem solvers with different perspectives, all working to build an inclusive society where everyone has a meaningful opportunity to thrive.
References
1. Moyser M, Milan A. Fertility rates and labour force participation among women in Quebec and Ontario. Statistics Canada. Jul 18 2018. Available at www.150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/en/pub/75-006-x/2018001/article/54976-eng.pdf?st=dps4T938.
2. Andrew-Gee E. How does Quebec’s universal daycare work, and what can the national $10-a-day programs learn from it? The Globe and Mail. Apr 16 2022. Available at https://www.theglobeandmail.com/canada/article-quebec-universal-daycare-lessons-10-a-day/.
3. Devercelli A, Beaton-Day F. Better Jobs and Brighter Futures: Investing in Childcare to Build Human Capital. World Bank. Dec 2020. Available at https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/server/api/core/bitstreams/a5e7a52e-115c-5dd1-97e6-c1b062c945c9/content
4. G20. 2025 G20 Summit Declaration. Available at https://g20.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/2025-G20-Summit-Declaration.pdf.
5. World Bank. Invest in Childcare. Apr 1 2025. Available at https://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/education/brief/investinchildcare.
6. Center for Global Development. Elevating the Childcare Agenda: What Could an Africa-US Partnership Look Like?. Dec 7 2022. Available at https://www.cgdev.org/blog/elevating-childcare-agenda-what-could-africa-us-partnership-look#:~:text=In%20African%20countries%20like%20Cote,early%20childhood%20care%20and%20education.
7. Center for Global Development. Filling Gaps in Childcare and Early Childhood Education Is Critical for Gender Equity and Economic Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa. Dec 17 2024. Available at https://www.cgdev.org/blog/filling-gaps-childcare-and-early-childhood-education-critical-gender-equity-and-economic-grown#:~:text=Strategic%20and%20coordinated%20policies%20are,under%20three%20and%20their%20caregivers.
8. Fraym. Calculating ROI for Caregiving Programs in Nigeria, Kenya, South Africa, and Indonesia. Available at https://fraym.io/case-studies/caregiving-roi-nigeria-kenya-south-africa-and-indonesia/#download.
9. International Center for Research on Women. Unpaid Care Work In Kenya: Evidence From The WEE Community of Practice Learning Agenda. Jun 2023. Available at https://www.icrw.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/Technical-Brief-Unpaid-Care-2_uid_64be3e40b7b18.pdf.
10. UN Women. Kenya advances toward a National Care Policy as data highlights urgent need for reform. Jul 11 2025. Available at https://africa.unwomen.org/en/stories/news/2025/10/kenya-advances-toward-a-national-care-policy-as-data-highlights-urgent-need-for-reform.
11. Action Aid. The Human Cost of Public Sector Cuts in Africa. May 2025. Available at https://actionaid.org/sites/default/files/publications/The%20Human%20Cost%20of%20Public%20Cuts%20May%202025.pdf.
12. Ilifa Labantwana. A Quantum Leap - The Ilifa Labantwana Story. Available at https://ilifalabantwana.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Ilifa-Phase-I-Strategy.pdf.