Addressing gendered social norms to enable the development of a formal care economy

Ayanda Mvimbi, a women’s economic empowerment specialist at UN Women

Loading Subtitles...

“Care is deeply gendered … if we grow and we live in a community where [care] is strictly seen as women needing to be staying home and just taking care of the kids and not participating in the economy, it is going to shape the whole ecosystem,” said Ayanda Mvimbi, a women’s economic empowerment specialist at UN Women, at a side event to the G20 in Johannesburg hosted by Economist Enterprise and supported by the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation. She continued, “So who does [provide] care and how it gets valued or not valued, and systems and mechanisms to inform financing and other plans are dependent on that [ecosystem] …In talking about care at different levels we really need to also start tackling the social norms because these social norms are drivers of what eventually policymakers end up making decisions about.”

Ayanda Mvimbi, a women’s economic empowerment specialist at UN Women

Loading Subtitles...

Social norms and the care economy

Social norms, which create an expectation that women and girls are primarily responsible for unpaid care work—including childcare, elder care, caring for a sick or disabled relative, and household chores—are one of the primary drivers of gender labour force participation gaps and gender economic disparities. Women and girls spend over double the amount of time each day on unpaid care work than men and boys do.1 If the total value of this unpaid care work was aggregated up, it would be more than 40% of GDP in some countries, according to the International Labour Organisation (ILO).2 And almost 380m women aged 25-54 are not in the labour force because of care responsibilities.3  

These social norms that prevent women from economic participation have serious consequences. Economist Enterprise’s Childcare Dividend Initiative, supported by the Gates Foundation, quantifies the losses that economies experience around the world because of mothers’ childcare burdens that prevent their participation in the formal labour force. The results are staggering: countries suffered up to US$12.6bn in 2022 in employment income losses as a result of employable mothers not participating in the workforce.

Hewlett Illustration Article two

But the problem does not end there. Not only do social norms around who bears responsibility for unpaid care affect women’s labour force participation, but they also affect perceptions of care work itself. Where formal or paid care work does exist, it can be a significant source of employment, particularly for women. Women make up two-thirds of the global care workforce (249m women compared with 132m men).4  And in South Africa alone, women make up 95% of childcare workers.5 Stigma, however, exists around this work. “One thing that we can take into account when talking about why [care work] is so undervalued is who are carers? In many cases, it’s domestic workers, it’s migrant women. So [carers are] already coming from a disadvantaged position and this is also one of the reasons why care is oftentimes undervalued,” says Jasmina Papa, a social protection specialist at ILO.

Jasmina Papa, a social protection specialist at the International Labour Organisation (ILO)

Loading Subtitles...

Zaheera Mohamed, chief executive of Ilifa Labantwana, an early childhood development programme in South Africa, has a different perspective on why care work is undervalued, but emphasises that stigma and social norms are a critical barrier to developing a formal, valued care economy. “The other discourse that we're working on shifting is that, because childcare is seen as care and as a social good, there's a tension around framing that as an enterprising opportunity. The concept of social enterprising is really hard for governments to get their head around … we're sitting with a situation where our caregivers are vilified for wanting to earn an income from care work.”

Conquering social norms to support women’s economic empowerment and a strong, formal care economy

Challenging social norms and gender stereotypes around caregiving responsibilities requires concerted effort across stakeholder groups. UN Women’s “Transformative Approaches to Recognize, Reduce and Redistribute Unpaid Care Work in Women’s Economic Empowerment Programming” programme was designed to address gender inequities in unpaid care in Rwanda, Senegal and South Africa. In particular, it aims to remove structural barriers to women’s full participation in the economy.6 

One of the core findings of this programme was the need to reward and represent paid care work to create the “5R Framework for Decent Care Work: Recognize, Reduce, and Redistribute unpaid care work, and Reward and Represent paid care work by promoting decent work for care workers and guaranteeing their representation, social dialogue and collective bargaining.”7 Eliminating discriminatory social norms and gender stereotypes—including enacting care-friendly employment policies and developing culturally -relevant education and advocacy campaigns—are key to achieving the 5Rs.

Equal paid parental leave for mothers and fathers is one way of enacting care-friendly policies. South Africa just took a major step forward with its October 2025 Constitutional Court ruling that challenged the country’s existing parental leave laws, which give women four months of leave and men just ten days. The new ruling now allows parents to split this four months and ten days between them in whatever way they choose.8

Zaheera Mohamed, chief executive of Ilifa Labantwana

Loading Subtitles...

At a more local level, organisations like Ilifa Labantwana are focused on trying to shift the stigma around care work and the care economy, specifically by targeting policymakers. Ms Mohamed says, “The next big phase of the work that we need to unlock is really starting to get micro-enterprise funding out, to recognise it [care work] as an income-earning opportunity.”

But there is still a long way to go. Governments should be focused on developing modules in school curricula and public advocacy and awareness campaigns to break social norms that reinforce perceptions that unpaid care work is the burden of women. They should also adjust parental care policies to place equal responsibility for childcare on men and women. The private sector can help to accelerate this shift by instituting its own parental leave policies that challenge existing gender norms, and create a culture that encourages men to use their paternity leave. 

Finally, governments must recognise that formal, paid care work is an effective way to increase women’s labour force participation—both in the care economy itself and across the broader economy—and to close the economic gender gap. This recognition will require a mindset shift, but the potential benefits speak for themselves: Nigeria alone could see a 1.09% increase in GDP in 2027 if mothers had access to affordable, accessible childcare and were able to join the workforce.

Supported by the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation

The William and Flora Hewlett Foundation invests in creative thinkers and problem solvers with different perspectives, all working to build an inclusive society where everyone has a meaningful opportunity to thrive.

References

1. UN Women. Care: A critical investment for gender equality and the rights of women and girls. Oct 29 2024. Available at https://www.unwomen.org/en/news-stories/statement/2024/10/care-a-critical-investment-for-gender-equality-and-the-rights-of-women-and-girls.

2. ILO. Why measuring unpaid domestic and care work matters, and how we can help. Available at https://ilostat.ilo.org/topics/unpaid-work/measuring-unpaid-domestic-and-care-work/.

3. ILO. The impact of care responsibilities on women’s labour force participation. Oct 2024. Available at https://www.ilo.org/sites/default/files/2024-10/GEDI-STAT%20brief_formatted_28.10.24_final.pdf

4. ILO. Care Work and Care Jobs for the Future of Decent Work. 2018. Available at https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---dgreports/---dcomm/---publ/documents/publication/wcms_633135.pdf

5. https://datausa.io/profile/soc/childcare-workers

6. UN Women. Evaluation of the Transformative Approaches to Recognize, Reduce, and Redistribute Unpaid Care Work in Women’s Economic Empowerment Programming. April 25, 2023. Available at https://www.unwomen.org/sites/default/files/2024-11/evaluation-recognize-reduce-and-redistribute-unpaid-care-work-in-womens-economic-empowerment-programming-executive-summary-en.pdf

7. UN Women. A Toolkit on Paid and Unpaid Care Work: From 3Rs to 5Rs. Jun 2022. Available at https://www.unwomen.org/sites/default/files/2022-06/A-toolkit-on-paid-and-unpaid-care-work-en.pdf

8. Muia W. Fathers entitled to equal parental leave, South Africa's top court rules. BBC News, Oct 3 2025. Available at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c0q7y5d0l3eo.