National-security concerns are hurting trade, but a new trade order is emerging
Supply chains have shifted from economic efficiency to national security. Here are the insights from John Ferguson, global lead of the Future of Trade initiative, from his panel discussion at Chatham House’s Global Trade Conference.
30 Mar 2026

The global trading system is undergoing a fundamental shift, with national-security concerns now supplanting efficiency. Self-sufficiency, control and resilience are taking precedence over traditional measures such as minimising cost and allocating resources according to comparative advantage. This is most evident across critical sectors such as telecommunications, energy and infrastructure.
As national-security considerations increasingly permeate nearly every sector, the system is becoming more judgment-based than rules-based. This introduces uncertainty and fragments markets, which is detrimental to global trade, growth and productivity. It also weakens the institutions that once underpinned global trade. The World Trade Organisation is struggling to maintain its relevance. Despite these disruptive trends, there are also nascent indications of a new, revised global-trading order beginning to emerge.
When rules give way to judgment in supply chains
Before turning to the emerging order, it is worth exploring how the old one is fraying. Today, decisions once governed by common rules now depend on political judgment.
The United States illustrates the trend. Despite the temporary relief following the US Supreme Court's reversal of President Trump's tariffs, the Economist Intelligence Unit anticipates a swift reinstatement of protectionist measures by the Trump administration through alternative legal avenues.[1]This expectation is already being realised with the revival of Section 301 investigations by the US trade representative, which extends scrutiny of “unfair practices” beyond China to a wider set of countries. This will probably be combined with Section 232 investigations, which are focused on national-security issues, demonstrating that national-security and foreign-policy concerns are a powerful motivator of the Trump administration’s approach to trade.
The result is discretion. Governments decide which countries pose risks, which industries matter and which practices are acceptable. If access to markets depends on political alignment rather than clear rules, firms and governments cannot rely on stable conditions, ultimately eroding trust in the system.
The European Union’s policies reflect the same logic. Its Foreign Subsidies Regulation, investment-screening mechanisms and even the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism all extend scrutiny of foreign firms (see box). Though framed in different terms—competition, security and climate—they share a common feature: they give policymakers discretion to judge whether external actors pose risks.
EU policies shaping trade and investment:
The Foreign Subsidies Regulation: This law evaluates potential mergers and acquisitions based on subsidies that foreign governments have provided to their companies.
The Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) Screening Mechanism: This screens inward FDI into the region.
The Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM): This imposes a cost on foreign companies exporting to the EU if their market does not have a domestic price on carbon.
National-security concerns are also driving trade policy in other areas. For example, in a geopolitical world where trust is in short supply, many Western countries are concerned about China’s grip on critical minerals. These minerals are deemed critical due to their use in a range of industries, including electric vehicles, clean energy and electronics. There are also signs that rules of origin, which determine where a product comes from, could be violated by concerns over who owns and controls production rather than where it is made. If this trend continues, a key pillar of the old trading order would cease to exist.
In response to this system in flux, multinational companies (MNCs) are employing “just-in-case” strategies—dual sourcing, higher inventories and redundancy in supply chains—to manage shocks. In the medium term, they are restructuring production through “friendshoring”, placing operations in countries seen as politically aligned.
These strategies raise costs, but reduce exposure to sudden policy shifts. MNCs are searching for predictability and reliable institutional structures to enable trade. Governments need the growth, innovation and productivity enhancements that trade provides. If like-minded countries and MNCs work together, these trends will be mutually reinforcing for trade openness.
Rebuilding rules amid fragmentation
The emerging order provides some hope to countries and MNCs that a new, more stable system can be built. Currently, there is a proliferation of regional, bilateral and plurilateral agreements being negotiated and implemented. For example, after 25 years of negotiations, the EU and Mercosur countries have signed a trade agreement.[2] The EU has also agreed to the “mother of all trade deals” with India. India and Middle Eastern countries such as the UAE have signed numerous agreements and will continue to liberalise trade.[3],[4]
Talks are also under way between the EU and members of the Comprehensive and Progressive Trans-Pacific Partnership, a deal that would bring 1.5bn people into a unified agreement. Common standards on rules of origin, streamlined investment screening[5] and regulatory alignment would give businesses exactly what they are crying out for—the confidence to commit, invest and plan for the long term. A deal of this scale would be more than symbolic. It would be a direct rebuke to the Trump administration, and proof that a critical mass of the world's leading economies can come together to create genuine stability in global markets.
Cautious optimism for a new trading order
The World Economic Forum in Davos earlier this year offered a glimpse of the two paths ahead for global trade. On one hand, President Trump’s threats—and subsequent climbdown—reminded Europe of the perils of relying on an administration inclined towards a “might is right” approach. On the other hand, Mark Carney, Canada’s prime minister, gave a much-talked-about speech about the agency of middle powers to shape the next phase of global affairs. The trade liberalisation under way demonstrates that agency in action.
The world will end up with a patchwork of bilateral, regional and plurilateral agreements of like-minded countries. And, while friendshoring will never be as clean as East, West and Neutral, these agreements will be powerful ways of signalling to the private sector who your friends are, at least in trade. The old trading order may have collapsed, but we are starting to see the initial contours of a new system for global trade.
References
- 1.
- 2.
- 3.
- 4.
- 5.