Advertisement feature
Coutts Logo

The consequences are already visible. Across the euro area, one in six industrial firms and one in four service firms cited labour shortages as a constraint on production in early 2025. In Britain, the effects are particularly acute: dairy and fruit farmers warn that worker shortages are threatening food security; the construction industry lacks the hands to build the 1.5m homes the government has promised; HGV driver vacancies remain stubbornly high; and NHS staffing gaps show no sign of closing. The fear is that shrinking workforces mean slower growth, stagnating productivity and, eventually, declining living standards.

But this fear has a notable weakness: it assumes that economies respond to scarcity by doing less, rather than by doing things differently. Faced with a dwindling number of workers, firms are being forced to find new ways of producing more with less. In doing so, they are accelerating the adoption of technologies that promise to lift productivity.

From scarcity to innovation

In the United States some of the largest businesses are demonstrating what this shift looks like in practice. Companies such as Walmart, General Motors and Bank of America have continued to grow revenues even as they invest heavily in automation and AI tools. It is productivity gains that are increasingly driving expansion.

The tipping point for productivity

Artificial intelligence is amplifying this trend. The Tony Blair Institute for Global Change estimates that widespread AI adoption could free up nearly a quarter of private-sector working time in Britain. These hours could be redirected towards new kinds of jobs. Over the longer term, gains like this could add significantly to national income.

Government projections point in a similar direction. Jobs involving AI are expected to rise sharply, from 158,000 in 2024 to almost 4m by 2035. Rather than replacing workers outright, the technology is reconfiguring work, shifting effort towards high-value activities.

These are projections, not certainties. Economists will recall the “productivity paradox” of the late 20th century, when heavy investment in computers took years to translate into measurable gains. Today’s surge in AI spending could follow a similar path, with benefits that are real but slow to appear.

Even so, there are reasons to think this wave may prove more immediate. The State of AI report by Nathan Benaich found 95% of professionals now use AI at work or home, 76% pay for AI tools out of their own pocket, and most report sustained productivity gains. The evidence that adoption has gone mainstream, suggests we are past the tipping point for widespread application and economic impact.

Transforming growth with “picks and shovels”

Coutts quote mark

AI is leading to genuine, tangible and measurable increases in productivity. In the near term, much of the value is in companies that supply the “picks and shovels” of AI—memory, chips and data centres.

Fahad Kamal, Chief Investment Officer at Coutts

In the near term, much of the value is in companies that supply the “picks and shovels” of AI—memory, chips and data centres. “The providers’ biggest problem is that they can't supply enough product. They’ve got more demand than they can possibly meet, with potential customers lining up outside the door,” says Kamal.

But it pays to balance experimentation with caution. “Narratives are shifting a lot. Who the winners are going to be at this stage, it's impossible to say.”

Ultimately, the guiding principle is earnings, a key financial metric revealing how much profit is allocated to each share. Kamal says: “The earnings from the AI buildout are pretty transparent and clear for the next two years. We're going to use wherever earnings are growing as our lodestar.”

In that sense, earnings are not just a measure of performance, but a signal of what is working. If worker shortage is the constraint, and AI the response, then the companies translating investment into profits may be laying the foundations for the productivity gains of the future. 

Explore more

Trade

A fractured trading system is expected to raise risks. But new alliances and supply chains are creating fresh opportunities too.

Read now

Longevity

Longer lives are transforming career paths, capital allocation and the meaning of legacy.

Read now
Learn more about Coutts

Commentary on investments is for information purposes only and should not be taken as advice. This content does not constitute investment advice.