How Toronto is winning the public transit pursuit
Each day, Toronto’s residents ride its subways, streetcars and buses 2.3m times—more than any city in North America apart from New York.
With 24-hour service, people use the 750 miles of public transportation routes to get to work, school or shopping centres because Toronto’s transit system offers something many other major cities in North America (including New York) do not: accessibility, affordability and inclusivity.
With carefully targeted investment and strategic planning, Toronto has achieved remarkable results.
It has figured out a way to get people out of their cars and on to public transportation.
And that is core to creating sustainable cities. Especially as every vehicle on the road releases an average of 1 lb of CO2 per mile driven. Getting citizens to switch to public transit can cut carbon emissions by almost half.
We visited Toronto to explore what other cities can leverage in their sustainability journeys. Our first revelation? Just C$3.30 will get you pretty much anywhere across the entire metro area, using the public transit system.
Affordability is a key factor for many Torontonians. Lower-income workers or those on fixed incomes who struggle to cover basic needs do not have to sacrifice mobility to pay for groceries or rent.
People like Meena Nathwani, who spent half her life riding the Toronto transit system to get to work and visit friends, are able to give up their cars without fear of isolation.
Now retired, Ms Nathwani, who had never taken a bus before emigrating to Canada from Tanzania, lives in a senior care development 22 miles north of downtown Toronto. Her commute these days is to visit her grandson each weekend. Rather than drive for 45 minutes in traffic, she travels by bus, train and streetcar—arriving to hug her grandson just 25 minutes later.
As Toronto has not only expanded but has become increasingly unaffordable for immigrants and seniors like Ms Nathwani, the city’s transit system remains a lifeline.
Without it, her world might feel much smaller.
Largely built after the second world war, Toronto’s public transport system was designed from the start to serve the fast-growing suburbs.
This gave newcomers a reliable alternative to cars.
It also helped create a denser, more sustainable city.
This, however, was not the case in Toronto, thanks to a series of critical decisions to serve the entire region. First came the creation of Metropolitan Toronto in 1953 which united the city and its suburbs on funding and future infrastructure. The modern Toronto Transit Commission (TTC) opened its first subway line a year later.
Next, in 1963, came the expansion of bus services into a massive grid that criss-crossed the suburbs. Unlike in other North American cities, regular service arrived in many cases before neighbourhoods were built, convincing developers to build taller, denser housing, while reducing the need for cars.
In 1971 the city abandoned plans to build a network of expressways, choosing instead to run a new subway line along the route. Also in that year, Toronto and the province of Ontario began supplying public funds for transit expansion, bolstering new development.
In each case, Toronto’s ability to plan, fund and build transit proved decisive in creating a city that was more equitable and accessible than its sprawling peers.
Today, Toronto’s street grid runs for more than 3,100 miles, nearly a quarter of which are served by bus or streetcar routes. Both connect seamlessly with the subways, creating a transportation network covering the entire Greater Toronto Area.
This multimodal system means Toronto’s subways are significantly busier on a per-mile basis than Washington’s or San Francisco’s which rely mainly on walk-ins or park-and-ride passengers. Toronto's frequent buses bring most riders to the subway. This not only makes the city's transit more efficient, but also enables passengers to travel further for work.
Key to this system are the suburban bus routes, the most frequent of which run 24/7. Nearly everyone lives within a 15-minute walk of round-the-clock service.
This enables riders like Ms Nathwani to travel downtown secure in the knowledge that a bus will come, day and night.
This reliability—while not always perfect—sets Toronto apart from other global cities.
According to the United Nations, only half of the world’s urban population has convenient access to transit, the absence of which hinders access to basic services and deepens social inequities.
Toronto’s next transit challenge is also its biggest opportunity to meet its climate goals: greening the city’s bus fleet. Whether powered by clean diesel, hydrogen fuel or electric batteries—all of which the TTC is testing—this transition will be pivotal to cutting emissions by 50% within a decade and reaching zero emissions by 2040.
All eyes are on Toronto, as no city in North America has fully embraced one technology over another.
But building a sustainable city demands more than green buses. It needs transit that is affordable, accessible and takes passengers where they want to go when they want to go.
This requires the foresight, leadership and public-private investments necessary to build a city best-suited to take advantage of it. Layer by layer, Toronto has achieved this.
This insight should inspire other rapidly growing cities—in sub-Saharan Africa and Asia, for example—where the world’s urban future is being written.
It’s a future that people like Ms Nathwani are counting on.
A city’s public transit system must serve all of its citizens, otherwise it simply fails—and as urban populations around the world grow, this will be core to building a sustainable future for generations to come.
Pilot: key findings report
Cities have become pivotal drivers of global economic expansion, contributing over 80% of the world’s GDP. They serve as hubs for opportunity, prosperity, innovation, and social and cultural interaction. Our Urban Performance Index report offers insights into policies to foster sustainable development and to enhance the quality of life in cities worldwide.
