Deep-sea mining (DSM) is an unproven industry seeking to extract primarily manganese, copper, cobalt, and nickel from the seabed. It is also the worst option to source those minerals because it is inefficient, unnecessary and destructive. In light of these concerns, numerous banks—including Deutsche Bank, Lloyds, NatWest, Standard Chartered, ABN Amro, Credit Suisse and BBVA—along with insurers and reinsurers like Hannover Re, Zurich Insurance Group, Vienna Insurance Group and Swiss Re, as well as major corporations such as First Solar, Google, Samsung, Volvo, BMW and Salesforce, are eschewing DSM (all as of March 2025).

The world does not need seabed minerals
The demand for seabed minerals has always been volatile, and it is now rapidly shrinking. According to the International Energy Agency's 2024 Global Electric Vehicle Outlook, “the price of all key battery metals dropped during 2023”, with supply outpacing demand for both cobalt and nickel. DSM advocates previously positioned it as a crucial solution for the energy transition. Technological advancements have rendered this argument obsolete—the battery industry has taken off, moving towards cheaper, safer and easier to procure minerals than those found on the seafloor. The emergence of a financially viable circular economy for metals further diminishes demand for seabed resources. A study commissioned by the International Seabed Authority, which is tasked with regulating potential DSM, found that “A decrease in prices for one or more of the four affected metals, caused by any reason…may result in some or even all seabed-mining projects becoming subeconomic or unprofitable.”
DSM is destructive and faces social opposition
DSM would strip-mine our ocean, destroying species we have yet to catalogue in the most stable and least understood ecosystem on earth. It would also involve a sediment discharge in open water. Scientists are concerned about the impacts DSM would have not only on the seabed but on the midwater column, including on whales and commercially important fisheries. DSM also faces opposition from Indigenous communities and human-rights concerns, and carries significant potential legal liabilities for all participants in DSM, including both public and private investors.

The sustainable DSM narrative is a myth
DSM fails to replace or mitigate the challenges associated with terrestrial mining; the volume of minerals extracted from the seabed would scarcely make a dent in the existing terrestrial supply. There is no consensus that DSM would be less harmful or have a lower impact, including to biodiversity or to the climate, than traditional mining practices. The European Academies Science Advisory Council has characterised the assertion that DSM is the “lesser of two evils” when compared with terrestrial mining as “misleading”. As the sustainability narrative surrounding DSM has been debunked, proponents have shifted their focus, attempting to create a fabricated demand for seabed minerals based on defence and infrastructure needs. However, demand for these minerals is volatile, and increased demand is not guaranteed; as battery chemistries change, supply has outpaced demand for specific metals.
An assault on our ocean, paid for by us
The financial models underpinning DSM are increasingly seen as unrealistic, failing to account for the numerous technical challenges associated with extraction, as well as the volatility of the metals market. For instance, the price of cobalt has plummeted by over 50% compared with industry forecasts made in 2021, and has dropped by more than 20% since the assumptions made in May 2024. Additionally, any rises in inflation and interest rates, when factored into the equations, would substantially diminish the projected profitability of DSM projects.
Compliance with intricate regulatory frameworks at various levels introduces further costs. The potential liabilities for environmental damage under international treaties and the demands for compensation from affected parties—such as fisheries, eco-tourism sectors and coastal nations—remain largely unexamined. A growing coalition of banks, insurers, corporations, and scientists have joined civil society in opposing DSM initiatives. In fact, 32 countries have called for a pause or outright ban on DSM activities. Despite this, insider interests and geopolitical dynamics continue to pose a threat, potentially positioning DSM alongside fossil-fuel-extraction and distant-water-fishing subsidies as significant assaults on our environment, all funded by the public. We must not allow it.
Views or opinions expressed are those of the author and any individuals cited, and do not necessarily reflect those of Economist Enterprise or any other member of The Economist Group.

