The International Seabed Authority (ISA) shapes critical policies governing the potential extraction of minerals from the seafloor. In early August, the member states of the ISA overwhelmingly elected a new secretary-General, Letitia Carvalho, by a vote of 79-34. This vote gives her a clear mandate for change, from someone who has considerable experience in environmental issues and oceanography. It is ultimately up to the member states to decide if the ISA should even allow deep-sea mining (DSM), and if so, under what circumstances. We are hopeful that she will bring far greater transparency and a more balanced methodology to the work of the ISA than her predecessor, who was seen as too aggressively pro-mining.



One area in which the new secretary-general can make a major impact is to invite greater discussion regarding the non-environmental aspects of DSM, because there has been remarkably little debate at the ISA over the widespread assumption that DSM will actually be profitable. The ISA should not be seen as just an environmental and regulation-focused body, but also one that encourages robust financial analysis to challenge the overly optimistic assumptions of industry proponents. If DSM will not realistically generate profits, there will be no royalties for member states and there is no need to damage the seafloor environment. The environmental debate would become moot.
For example, the ISA should start by encouraging questioning the assumed costs of seafloor mineral extraction and processing. The period from 2020-24 has seen the highest level of inflation in over 40 years. However, in the publicly filed financials of DSM leader The Metals Company (TMC), how much change has there been in their published cost estimates during that time frame? Zero.



There is also the somewhat arcane yet absolutely crucial matter of calculating the economic net present value (NPV) of the seafloor-mining business cases that have been used to justify their approval. In order to evaluate economic projects, NPV analysis is used, but it is based on a crucial assumption: the interest rate used to “discount” the value of future cash flows. Shockingly, despite interest rates spiking to more than twice what they were in 2021 when TMC’s DSM financial models were presented, this critical value has remained not only unchanged but at an unrealistically low rate of just 9%. If current metal prices, realistic cost increases, and an accurate discount rate is used, the NPV would be at or close to zero.
Furthermore, battery technology has begun to dramatically shift away from using cobalt, manganese and nickel. To give just one example: lithium-iron phosphate batteries have doubled to 40% of worldwide EV-battery production from 2020 to 2023, and they use none of the three key elements that are mined through DSM. DSM is a 30-year bet that battery chemistries will not move away from using expensive, conventional nickel-cobalt-manganese batteries—which is an extremely poor bet given the rate of technological change in the industry. The ISA, under the new secretary-general , should encourage more reviews of these dramatic technological developments that challenge the need for minerals from the seafloor in the first place.


Likewise, the prices of key metals that drive DSM profitability are down significantly from 2021. Cobalt is down a staggering 52%; and nickel is down a significant 12% since March 2021—even though the number of electric vehicles has increased by more than five times. The assumption by industry was that dramatic increases in EV sales would drive prices of the metals up, not down. But lack of demand and significantly increased terrestrial production have made key minerals in DSM far less profitable to mine. So much nickel has flooded the market that major mines in Australia, New Caledonia and other areas are being mothballed. If major terrestrial nickel mines are being mothballed, why the need for seafloor mining?

A final detail that is overlooked in the DSM debate that should be encouraged by the new secretary-general is the significance of the amount of material that can be realistically mined from the seafloor. Even the prospective leader in the field, TMC, at its maximum production rate would produce less than 2.5% of projected 2030 worldwide nickel supply, and that percentage is even less for copper and manganese. Any statement or even suggestion that seafloor mining would materially replace terrestrial mining, with its significantly lower costs and greater accessibility, is simply false.
The focus at the ISA historically seems to have been almost exclusively on the environmental aspects of DSM. However, the economic and technical assumptions of DSM have not been adequately challenged at all by experienced financial, economic or risk-assessment professionals and examination of these factors must be strongly encouraged if not demanded by the ISA just as diligently and critically as the environmental aspects have been. It is my sincere hope that Secretary-General Carvalho helps foster greater transparency and thoroughness regarding all aspects of DSM, especially the financial and technological dimensions.
Views or opinions expressed are those of the author and any individuals cited, and do not necessarily reflect those of Economist Enterprise or any other member of The Economist Group.
All wildlife pictures in the blog are credited to Caladan Oceanic/University of Western Australia/Minderoo
Header image: Unsplash

