Advertisement feature
Worldpay logo

For retailers, January brings a peculiar paradox. As the frenetic pace of holiday shopping subsides, merchants may find themselves out of sorts, managing depleted inventory in some categories and excess stock in others. Meanwhile, extended return windows — some stretching back to November purchases — create a complex dance of refunds and replenishment, straining cashflow and supply chains. Yet this slower period also offers an opportunity to address the technical debt accrued during the end-of-year rush to serve ever more demanding customers.

The numbers tell a compelling story about consumers’ expectations when it comes to what they want and how they would like to pay for it. Against a backdrop of proliferating sales channels, multiplying digital wallets and increasingly rapid returns, consumers rate payments at more than eight out of ten in terms of importance1, according to a 2024 report by Worldpay, a leading payments technology and solutions company. In addition, an overwhelming 96% of respondents prioritise easy returns and refunds2, two-thirds of whom expect them within 24 hours — a demand that would have seemed unreasonable just a few years ago. This shifting landscape requires merchants to optimise their payment systems for both speed and efficiency.

The new year is their chance to act on these resolutions. Throughout the Christmas shopping period, many retailers implement what the industry calls “peak freeze” — a moratorium on system updates to minimise disruptions. “Now’s the time for changes they might have held off on over the peak,” explains Oliver Banks, founder of retail consultancy OB&Co and author of Driving Retail Transformation. How merchants manage to meet customers’ growing demands while reducing their own costs will set up their year for success, he adds.

Post-Christmas headaches

A woman looking at her smartphone while carrying wrapped gifts

The challenges extend beyond seasonality. With 94% of shoppers demanding diverse payment options3 and 84% wanting one-click payments4, merchants must ruthlessly prioritise what to implement. They cannot afford to chase a long tail of costly and unnecessary features. Careful analysis and segmentation is essential. “You need to know who your shopper is and where you are getting most of your transactions,” advises Maria Prados, senior vice president of go-to-market at Worldpay. “How many payment processes do you have? How many countries do they cover? Where do you want to expand? And what can you consolidate?”

International payments and currencies only add complexity. According to Worldpay’s recent retail payments performance report, the vast majority (94%) of consumers prioritise local-currency options5, while nearly all (99%)6 see it as important to be able to use their preferred payment method. This means merchants must deftly offer multi-currency pricing, reconciling the figures recorded in their systems with seamlessly translated prices. For returns, such transactions face further complications, as exchange rates are likely to have shifted since purchase.

A man sitting at a table, deeply focused while reviewing documents, with a laptop, notebook, and coffee cup nearby in a well-lit home setting.

Fraud is another bugbear that reaches a fever pitch during the holidays. But a zero-tolerance policy may cost more than it is worth, as overly onerous authentication and repeatedly rejected transactions lead would-be customers to abandon their carts. “You can’t operate at 0% fraud,” warns Ms Prados. “It has to be part of your operating model — albeit understood, controlled and regulated.” An example is so-called “friendly fraud” — where legitimate customers file inappropriate chargebacks — which requires sophisticated detection systems capable of distinguishing between genuine claims and opportunistic abuse without creating excessive friction.

New year, new opportunities

A person showing a tablet to another person in a store. The second person holds a shopping bag. Shelves with items are in the background.

Yet within these challenges lie opportunities. Payment data, often viewed merely as a back-office concern, can drive customer personalisation, retention and lifetime value. “We have more data about each shopper at the payment level than anywhere else,” notes Ms Prados.

Coupled with AI’s pattern recognition capabilities, this information can be used to streamline the customer experience — by automatically prioritising their preferred payment at checkout, for instance — and to transform returns from a cost centre into a sales generator. “Returns are much more difficult to deal with than sales,” says Mr Banks. “If you can forecast your sales with some volatility, returns are a different challenge entirely — you need to keep very close track of your working capital.”

By instantly refunding the purchase — rather than making customers wait days or weeks for their credit — merchants might immediately present personalised alternatives more likely to resonate with the new shopper, potentially turning what could have been a loss into their first transaction of many. For repeat customers, returns provide an opportunity to introduce them to new channels — from online to brick-and-mortar and vice versa — which may better suit their needs. “How can you allow that customer more time to consider the products, weigh up different options, choose add-ons?” asks Mr Banks. “However they want to shop, they can progress through that.”

A man using his smartphone to make a contactless payment at a coffee shop, with a coffee cup on the counter and a modern, bright interior in the background.

Success in this new landscape requires a fundamental shift in how merchants view payments — from a mere transaction mechanism to a core driver of customer experience and loyalty. Those who use the post-holiday period to enhance their payment infrastructure may find the traditional slow season becomes a springboard for sustained growth. By treating every return as an opportunity to win a new customer and every transaction as a chance to deepen relationships, merchants can transform the challenges of modern retail into competitive advantage. In doing so, they may discover that the January doldrums are not so much a time for belt-tightening, but a time to lay the groundwork for the year ahead.

Register

Join Economist Enterprise's on-demand webinar, sponsored by Worldpay, for valuable insights into the evolving world of digital payments. Through expert-led discussion and practical examples from industry leaders, explore key trends shaping the future of payments. Gain actionable knowledge to navigate and innovate in this rapidly changing landscape. Register today to stay informed and prepared for what’s next.

Sign up
webinar image
Worldpay logo
Find out more from Worldpay 
Produced byE² Studio logo
References