Turning treaties into action: what’s next for ocean governance

From plastics to high seas agreements, speakers at the 10th annual World Ocean Summit highlighted recent wins and the power of multilateralism

13 Apr 2023

From plastics to high seas agreements, speakers at the 10th annual World Ocean Summit highlighted recent wins and the power of multilateralism

From putting an end to plastic pollution and harmful fish subsidies to enabling ecosystem protection, international agreements on ocean governance have made some tidal-sized waves over the past 18 months. 

“I've chaired the World Ocean Summit eight times,” said Zanny Minton Beddoes, editor-in-chief of The Economist, at the recent 10th annual World Ocean Summit. “Each year I'm always wondering whether the glass is more half full than half empty. But we are gradually making progress. And multilateralism isn't in a very good place in many areas right now. But are the oceans an exception?”

Speakers at the summit expressed optimism about the many high-level global treaties that have recently been agreed and emphasised the value of multilateralism, yet warned that we need to involve impacted communities in the decision-making processes to turn commitments into meaningful, equitable action. One controversial topic that was on many people’s minds throughout the conference was deep-sea mining (DSM) and what the international response should be around allowing DSM to happen before its environmental impacts are better understood. 

Major steps forward for ocean deals that have been decades in the making

COP26 in Glasgow was one of the first high-level international spaces to give a platform to ocean issues in the context of climate and sustainable development. It arguably accelerated action towards protecting ocean health and shaping a sustainable ocean economy. 

“COP26 was a real opportunity and we were able to put that focus on our oceans,” said Mairi Gougeon, cabinet secretary for rural economy and islands in Scotland.  “As a result, we’re really taking the opportunity to integrate and strengthen our ocean-based climate actions and embed the UNFCCC architecture [in our blue-economy strategy].” 

Since then, multiple international agreements addressing a number of interrelated ocean challenges have come to the fore including a treaty to end plastic pollution, an agreement to end harmful fishing subsidies, a historic “deal for nature”—the Global Biodiversity Framework (GBF) that aims to protect 30% of the planet’s natural spaces by 2030—and an agreement to establish a legally binding instrument to safeguard the high seas.

Multilateralism is key in addressing ocean issues and everyone has a part to play

Speakers pointed out that even in the face of interrelated global challenges like climate change, covid-19, conflict, energy and food crises, and others, recent wins in blue governance show that multilateral co-operation for ocean action is alive and well. 

“Every ambassador [has to be committed], especially the people and citizens as well. They have to press leaders to make decisions. Everybody thinks the ocean is important. Now we have to prove it,” said Olivier Poivre d’Arvor, ambassador to poles and oceans for the French government. “COP15 was a great surprise for everybody because [negotiations] started during covid and then had to move to Montreal, and Montreal was a huge success. We had this agreement [to protect 30% of nature] by the end of 2030, which is extraordinary.”

One way that Scotland ensures that multilateralism doesn’t ignore local communities or leave stakeholders behind is through a “shared-stewardship” approach. 

“A shared-stewardship approach to our marine environment underpins our vision for a blue economy in Scotland,”  said Ms Gougeon. “Working with people and taking them alongside us in a way that involves the communities who depend on these different industries is [critical to success].”

Angela Paolini Ellard, deputy director-general at the World Trade Organisation (WTO) explained how the WTO Agreement on Fisheries Subsidies—an agreement 20 years in the making—gives her hope that effective multilateral ocean action is well under way. While there are still additional bureaucratic hurdles in place to fully implement the agreement, some WTO members are already taking the necessary actions to assess and report on problematic fishing subsidies and issues around illegal and unreported (IUU) fishing. She emphasised the importance of understanding the different needs of developing and least-developed countries, and how providing funding to implement the agreement in these areas was a key part of the negotiations.  

More data and transparency is needed to address the elephant in the room: deep-sea mining

The year 2023 is meant to be a decisive year for establishing rules and regulations on deep-sea mining. But a number of countries, companies, scientists and environmental groups have publicly voiced concern over the potential ramifications of allowing DSM before its environmental impacts are fully understood. 

Speakers agreed that more data is needed to move forward with DSM. France, for example, will ban DSM in its waters and is calling for a moratorium or “precautionary pause” on DSM until there is enough science and data to show it can be done in an environmentally sustainable way. 

“The ocean is in such bad condition,” said Mr Poivre d’Arvor. “And we don't know what the effect of DSM will be on the environment.” 

“The lesson here, not just with respect to DSM, but more broadly, is the importance in this type of negotiation of having the right data, having data that all members can agree on as being the basis for making decisions,” said Ms Ellard. “And that's all based on transparency and on creating an atmosphere of negotiation in which there really is this type of transparency.”

“The ocean is in such bad condition. And we don't know what the effect of DSM will be on the environment"

EXPERT TALK

Insights from the 10th annual World Ocean Summit

Start of carousel.

Wind, wave, sun and more: could ocean-based power help alleviate a growing energy crisis?
Biodiversity, Ecosystems & Resources

Wind, wave, sun and more: could ocean-based power help alleviate a growing energy crisis?

Experts at the 10th annual World Ocean Summit highlighted how blue-energy projects can be designed to support conservation, aquaculture and more

WOS23 - NBS
Biodiversity, Ecosystems & Resources

Blue nature-based solutions: a win for biodiversity, climate and community

Experts at the 10th annual World Ocean Summit stressed the importance of co-creating solutions

WOS23 - governance
Sustainable Ocean Economy

Turning treaties into action: what’s next for ocean governance

From plastics to high seas agreements, speakers at the 10th annual World Ocean Summit highlighted recent wins and the power of multilateralism

WOS23 - MPAs
Ocean Health

Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) will be key to protecting 30% of the planet by 2030

Experts at the 10th annual World Ocean Summit agreed that monitoring and managing MPAs is challenging, but that collaborative solutions can help

WOS23 blue finance image
Sustainable Ocean Economy

An ocean of opportunity: how the private sector can fuel blue finance

Experts at the 10th annual World Ocean Summit expressed hope that the “tide is turning” when it comes to scaling blue finance

From fish scales to microalgae: Collaboration is key in blue biotech
Supported by Oceano Azul Foundation
Biodiversity, Ecosystems & Resources

From fish scales to microalgae: Collaboration is key in blue biotech

Panellists at the World Ocean Summit discuss the challenges—and wide-reaching potential—of marine biotechnology

WOS ocean data
Ocean Health

From data sets to data flows: making the case for open-source ocean science

Experts at the 10th annual World Ocean Summit explained how sharing information and creative communication can benefit the entire ocean community

WOS23 Peak Plastic
Ocean Health

Peak plastic: how we can solve the plastics problem within a generation

Experts at the 10th annual World Ocean Summit highlighted holistic solutions and got detailed about what the forthcoming global plastics treaty could look like

WOS23 - sustainable tourism
Biodiversity, Ecosystems & Resources

Regenerative coastal tourism: protecting the planet through unforgettable experiences

Speakers at the 10th annual World Ocean Summit highlighted the planet-saving power and profitability of regenerative blue tourism

Net-zero shipping
Sustainable Ocean Economy

Net-zero shipping: how maritime transport can rapidly reduce emissions

Speakers at the 10th annual World Ocean Summit said the industry wants to decarbonise, but a lack of regulatory and market drivers is getting in the way

End of carousel.