Impact Economist Logo

Measuring the urgency for childcare investment and policy reform

Supported by
Scroll down

Online, there is a vast conversation about the urgent need for better childcare: just last year, 4.5 million users posted about this topic on Twitter.

The covid-19 pandemic shone a light on the invisible work that enables childcare provision and the disproportionate impact that this work has had on women’s economic advancement. Women stepped in to fill the childcare gap and bore the consequences economically. It is estimated that the pandemic cost women globally at least US$800bn in lost income in 2020—more than the combined GDP of 98 countries.1

The situation of families—particularly mothers—had been described as a ‘global childcare crisis’ even before the onset of the pandemic.2 As the effects of the pandemic continue to be felt around the world, the childcare emergency remains top of mind for millions of families. Over the past year alone, there were over 15.6 million tweets on childcare across the world.

A deep dive into these posts gives us an insight into how people engage with childcare topics, who is driving the conversation and what specific childcare topics people are engaging with the most.

15.6
million tweets on childcare across the world in the past one year
Volume of conversations on childcare globally over the past one year (total number of tweets)
HoverClick to explore
Key topics of conversation on childcare globally over the past one year
HoverClick to explore
26 February
2022
25 June
2022
24 June
2022
27 August
2022
19 November
2021

Engagement and awareness

Most tweets originate in childcare ‘laggard’ countries.

More than twice the number of users that tweeted about childcare were from nine countries classified as ‘laggards’ compared with 11 countries classified as ‘leaders’ or ‘emerging’ childcare service providers.

Classification of countries by state of provision of childcare services*
Leader
Emerging
Laggard
Chile
Bangladesh
Australia
Germany
Canada
Brazil
South Korea
India
Kenya
Indonesia
Nigeria
Jordan
Uganda
Mexico
United Arab Emirates
South Africa
United Kingdom
Tanzania
United States of America
Vietnam
*Detailed note highlighting process of classification is included in the methodology
Volume of conversations on childcare in countries identified as ‘leaders’, ‘emerging’ and ‘laggards’, in the provision of childcare services (total number of tweets)

Content

Accessibility, affordability and quality top the list of concerns.

Access dominated the discussion across the 20 countries examined, with almost half of childcare conversations centred on this topic on Twitter. In countries classified as ‘laggards’ in childcare provision, accessibility was the greatest concern.

Volume of conversations on childcare segregated by form of content (% of tweets)
Accessibility
Affordability
Quality
Volume of conversations on childcare segregated by form of content and region (% of tweets)
Overview of volume of conversations on childcare segregated by form of content across all 20 countries (% of tweets)
HoverClick to explore
Accessibility

Access to childcare schemes, poor infrastructure and inferior allowances for childcare workers were the top issues in half the countries.

Accessibility was a more common topic of discussion and a greater concern in middle- and low-income countries than high-income nations.

  • For more #women to enter the workforce, we need access to better childcare services.
    #twitter
  • Parenting is one of life’s greatest joys but it can be a massive struggle to balance children, work and bills. We need better leave policies and facilities!
    #twitter
  • Parents are struggling to secure #childcare spots!
    #twitter
  • Access and outrageous costs prevent those most in need from receiving any childcare benefits.
    #twitter
Key topics of conversation around ‘accessibility’ across all 20 countries
HoverClick to explore
Countries where ‘accessibility’ was the most frequently expressed form of content in conversations around childcare (% of tweets)
HoverClick to explore
Affordability

In high-income countries, affordability was the primary concern. High costs, poor funding and low wages for providers were the key topics.

Expanding affordable childcare on a universal basis remains a prominent topic of discussion in countries like the US.

  • #Childcare was more than my tuition, it was more than my rent!
    #twitter
  • You know what would help parents? Including out of school care in affordable child care funding. Out of school care shouldn’t cost more than full-time childcare!
    #twitter
  • The cost of childcare pushed my wife out of the workforce. It’s so absurdly expensive! Sending two kids would cost more than 100% of her wages.
    #twitter
  • Recently the #minimum wage was raised. Childcare is already expensive, but if the government could come in to help with the costs.
    #twitter
Key topics of conversation around ‘affordability’ across all 20 countries
HoverClick to explore
Countries where ‘affordability’ was the most frequently expressed form of content in conversations around childcare (% of tweets)
HoverClick to explore
Quality

It’s not enough to have low-cost, accessible childcare if it is low quality, a third of users noted.

Quality concerns were largely centred around health, nutrition and education in middle- and low-income countries, with training, safety and overall service provision across the wider expanse of countries.

  • As the first outpost for health, nutrition, childhood care and early learning services, childcare centres play an important role.
    #twitter
  • About the crèche issue, can organisations have their own crèches? As a would-be mother tomorrow, I want to know and feel that my baby is #safe.
    #twitter
  • Quality, accessible childcare is among the most important investments a country can make!
    #twitter
  • 2 lakh Anganwadis [rural child care centres] to be upgraded with better facilities. Find real-time updates on the Budget.
    #twitter
Key topics of conversation around ‘quality’ across all 20 countries
HoverClick to explore
Countries where ‘quality’ was the most frequently expressed form of content in conversations around childcare (% of tweets)
HoverClick to explore

Function

Most of the people commenting on childcare on social media are those directly impacted: parents.

Tweets served a variety of functions, including social conversations, activism, institutional communication and media sharing. In 14 out of the 20 countries examined, more than half of the tweets were social conversations.

Growth in the childcare sector has largely been driven by private providers and individuals incentivised to intervene because of their own experiences and the need to fill an existing gap. To put it simply, the people who are most concerned about childcare are the ones directly impacted by issues within this sector—people and families. There is now a need to reframe the conversation to present childcare as a ‘public good’ rather than a public ‘want' or a ‘nice to have'.

Percentage of tweets tagged as activism, media sharing, social conversation and institutional communication
Activism
Institutional communication
Media sharing
Social conversation
Volume of conversations on childcare segregated by function and region (% of tweets)
HoverClick to explore
Volume of conversations on childcare segregated by function and income-group (% of tweets)
HoverClick to explore
Social conversations

Most childcare tweets are social in nature—parents looking for community and advice.

Most users leveraged the platform to express their opinions, document experiences, request information, and voice their childcare needs.
  • I am only entitled to two days of paid paternity leave in my country, so 16-weeks paid parental leave policy is a massive upgrade for me
    #twitter
  • Women tend to spend lower incomes more on collective household goods e.g. childcare. #Vat burden disproportionately falls on lower-income women.
    #twitter
  • I want to start a daycare and play for kids in my flat. Who can guide me for required licences and issuer names with process?
    #twitter
  • Is parenting the same as nurturing? My point on nurturing is from the perspective of childcare, nutrition and health, NOT attention, guidance, security.
    #twitter
Activism

Advocacy is low online. Only 7% of tweets called for policy reform or social change.

Of the 6 regions examined, North America recorded the largest share of activism-related tweets, with 12% of total mentions. In the Middle East and Latin America, less than 1% of all tweets examined were related to activism.
  • Our laws should be amended starting with the law of the Child Act, 2009 to better suit the needs of the child in this modern century!
    #twitter
  • Support contraception, government paid parental leave, publicly-funded daycare. All of these policies may well reduce abortion rates.
    #twitter
  • Amend the Maternity Benefit Act, 1961 to give adoptive mothers equal maternity benefits!
    #twitter
  • Mother of 5 who was raised by a working mother. Why am I facing the same issues in 2022 that my mom faced in 1970? We need affordable childcare and gender-equality!
    #twitter
Institutional communication

Communication from governments and childcare providers is low compared with social conversations.

Only 18% of all conversations examined were tagged as institutional communication.
  • As a nanny, you have to prove trustworthy for a parent to hire you. One step is by joining a professional #nanny training. If this is your dream, look no further!
    #twitter
  • We are looking for #EdTech innovators who are improving access to quality and relevant early childhood education across Sub-Saharan Africa.
    #twitter
  • Get certified on ECCE with us! Our programme will help you develop a well-crafted syllabus and curriculum.
    #twitter
  • We provide the most competitive early childhood care and education for children under the age of 5 and increase the viability of future enrolment.
    #twitter
Media sharing

The same is true for media.

Compared to 49% social conversations, only 26% of conversations were tagged as media sharing.
  • In the case of adoptions, commissioning and adopting mothers will get 12-week-long maternity benefits, as per the new amendment.
    #twitter
  • Increasing number of reforms made in pay & workplace indicators including childcare. Economic inclusion & participation of women is critical to a country’s development.
    #twitter
  • When it comes to childcare access, where you live matters!
    #twitter
  • Childcare is an investment in the future of our society, just like well-funded public education.
    #twitter

Families continue to fill the gap in childcare provision through invisible work—and at the expense of their productive and financial wellbeing.

Childcare is still seen as a private matter despite its economic and social repercussions. Our analysis of millions of conversations around the world reveals the urgency for policy reform and investments in infrastructure to ensure access to childcare.

It also reveals that there is ample room for institutions and providers to engage more with the general population in order to understand and address their needs and offer better solutions to bridge the childcare gap.

Blue watercolor illustration overlaying a bar chart with 4 descending bars
Measuring the urgency
Download report
watercolor illustration of house
Back to home
Learn more