Catherine McKenna

Blog

Towards a fair green transition

An interview with Catherine McKenna

Published 1 Dec, 2024 • 5 min read

The escalating climate crisis demands an urgent transition to a green economy. The global move to a sustainable, low-carbon economy is essential for addressing climate change and is an opportunity to redefine economic and social equity. Catherine McKenna, a former Canadian minister of environment and climate change and minister of infrastructure and communities, provides valuable insights into managing this complex and urgent challenge.

As a former minister of environment and climate change, and a minister of infrastructure and communities, what are the challenges in making the green transition fair or just?

Addressing the complexities of a just transition is challenging. The concept involves advancing the energy transition while ensuring economic opportunities are created and workers and communities are not left behind. While this sounds straightforward in principle, it is difficult in practice. The obstacles include job displacement and community impacts, as well as broader challenges like political resistance, misinformation and public scepticism.

For example, in Canada, the term ‘just transition’ has prompted some backlash, as many perceived it as a precursor to job cuts without a plan for alternatives. This highlights the need for clear communication and policies demonstrating tangible benefits, such as job creation and economic development, to build trust and support among affected communities. Ensuring fairness requires addressing these interconnected challenges through thoughtful, inclusive strategies that balance economic, social and political considerations.

Man at computer with maps and cgi of wind turbines

From your experience, how should policymakers define and measure ‘justice’ in this context?

Justice is not only defined by governments; it also concerns how affected communities perceive the transition. This means listening to their fears, hopes and ideas, even when the answers are difficult. For instance, in 2018 we launched a Task Force on Just Transition for Canadian Coal Power Workers as part of Canada’s coal phase-out efforts. The findings from the task force signalled the anger and frustration of the coal workers. These workers were not just worried about jobs—they were grappling with the potential unravelling of their entire way of life. Listening to the communities affected by green transition policies is not just about ticking a box; it is an outcome. Showing up matters and being honest about what we can and cannot do matters even more.

How can governments balance the benefits and costs of the green transition, ensuring the fairness and inclusion of the most vulnerable communities?

A just transition is incredibly challenging and deeply personal for the communities it affects. From my experience, engaging with these communities required acknowledging their anger, frustration and sadness directly, while fostering open, respectful dialogue. It was essential to listen to and validate their concerns, and respond transparently. Recognising the surprise and sometimes cynicism that the government was there to listen, we focused on building trust by ensuring follow-up actions, maintaining consistent communication and demonstrating a genuine commitment to addressing their needs. It builds trust and shows people that their experiences and concerns are respected. Communities want to know their concerns are being taken seriously, especially around actual costs like retraining, relocation or infrastructure. As the Mapping Justice in National Climate Action report lays out, the idea of procedural justice is important here—ensuring that affected groups have meaningful participation in decision-making. Governments must engage with communities, listen to their concerns, and provide honest assessments of costs and benefits. Rebuilding trust requires clear and sustained communication, especially about the financial and social implications of policy changes.

Aligning environmental and infrastructure policies to support transitioning communities can be challenging. Effective transitions require collaboration across relevant ministries and departments. As a Minister of Environment and Climate Change, I had to work with other ministries looking at finance, infrastructure, human resources, and even justice to align our efforts. Communities also need long-term certainty rather than plans that change with political cycles and commitments they can count on.

Greenwashing is also a major barrier to credible climate action. As we argue in the Integrity Matters report, governments and non-state actors must establish robust mechanisms to ensure measurable actions follow commitments. Moreover, there is a risk of entrenched interests and climate sceptics using misinformation and disinformation to amplify public distrust by framing green policies as economically harmful. This occurs amid global exhaustion, from COVID-19 to economic inflation, making it harder to rally public support for ambitious climate action. Governments must counter this narrative with clear, evidence-based messaging that highlights the economic opportunities of the transition.

What are the key political challenges in the just transition, particularly when engaging communities, navigating government co-ordination and addressing communication gaps with politicians?

In my experience, the political challenges surrounding the green transition are deeply rooted in public scepticism and misinformation. First, there is a general cynicism towards politicians—people seem sceptical about politicians genuinely caring about their jobs or them helping create new ones. This lack of trust makes the process harder. Second, disinformation is a significant barrier. Similarly, entrenched interests and climate sceptics amplify public distrust by framing green policies as economically harmful. Climate disinformation undermines public trust and makes bipartisan support harder to achieve.

Political realities often complicate climate policies. In Canada, regional divides and economic inequality hinder a fair green transition. Resource-rich provinces like Alberta and Saskatchewan feel unfairly targeted by emission-reducing policies. These regions contribute significantly to the national economy and view such measures as punitive. There is also frustration over global emissions, especially when people see China expanding coal production while Canada closes its coal plants. These concerns, though understandable, need to be addressed with empathy and clear communication.

It is crucial to mention the broader political context here. In the aftermath of the covid-19 pandemic, flushed with macroeconomic downturns, it is even more crucial for politicians to communicate why the green transition matters and the opportunities it presents.

Can countries with diverse economic and social contexts align on following the same just transition principles? What challenges do lower-income economies face when it comes to green transition?

Man at computer with maps and cgi of wind turbines

Transitioning away from coal and other fossil fuels in developing countries is a complex and challenging process. In many communities, these are not just energy sources, but often the backbone of their economy. Shutting down coal plants without providing alternative jobs and support for workers and communities dealing with poverty is in itself a political challenge.

The financial and technical support needed to manage the green transition is enormous, and while there is capital available globally, many countries lack the expertise to implement solutions effectively. The Just Energy Transition Partnerships initiative aims to bring together financial resources and expertise for the matter, but co-ordination remains a significant challenge. On top of that, there are political and economic risks, like currency fluctuations or instability, that make progress even harder.

From my time as a minister, I have learned that successful transitions require creativity, empathy and a deep understanding of local contexts. Politicians in these regions are under immense pressure and need our support. Phasing out fossil fuels and accelerating the adoption of green energy sources is crucial for the planet, but we need to approach them with pragmatism and understanding, balancing global goals with the realities on the ground.

How can the international community and development partners help address these challenges?

The international community must unite to share knowledge, finance and technology, with development partners facilitating the process. Initiatives like the Just Energy Transition Partnerships are promising models, but require sustained effort and innovation to succeed.

The cost of capital remains a significant issue, and multilateral development banks must shift their approach to risk and return. For example, we restructured the Canada Infrastructure Bank by putting an emphasis on de-risking projects to attract private capital rather than prioritising high returns. The goal should be reducing greenhouse gases while bringing in private capital and achieving measurable outcomes. We must focus on providing ‘risk capital’ to enable transformative projects that otherwise struggle to secure funding. Additionally, we must secure targeted financing to support workers in industries transitioning away from carbon-intensive activities. Financial institutions and private-sector actors can adopt innovative blended financial mechanisms to speed up transitions through risk-sharing and investments aligned with net-zero goals. Public and private finance must bridge the gaps in infrastructure, technology transfer and social protections, especially in developing countries. Without addressing these issues, political resistance will persist. Wealthier nations must provide necessary support before imposing transition burdens on poorer countries.

Catherine Mckenna

Catherine McKenna, Founder and principal of Climate and Nature Solutions

Catherine McKenna is the founder and principal of Climate and Nature Solutions and chairs the UN Secretary-General’s High-Level Expert Group on Net-Zero Commitments for Non-State Entities, which includes companies, investors, cities, and regions. She is also a Distinguished Visiting Fellow at Columbia University’s Climate School, where she launched the “Women Leading on Climate” initiative at COP26.

Previously, Catherine was Canada’s Minister of Environment and Climate Change under Prime Minister Justin Trudeau. At COP21 in Paris, France invited her to facilitate the negotiation of Article 6 of the Paris Agreement, which focused on global carbon markets. She led the creation of Canada’s first national climate plan, which included a nationwide price on pollution. Her leadership extends to global initiatives like the Powering Past Coal Alliance, the Ministerial on Climate Action, and the Nature Champions Summit.

In her subsequent role as Minister of Infrastructure and Communities, Catherine championed investments in public transport and sustainable infrastructure. She played a key role in attracting private investment through the Canada Infrastructure Bank and led the development of Canada’s first National Infrastructure Assessment, aimed at achieving net-zero emissions by 2050.

Before entering politics, Catherine practised trade law in Canada and Indonesia, served as a legal adviser to the United Nations Transitional Authority in East Timor, and co-founded Canadian Lawyers Abroad (now Level). A dedicated mother of three, she enjoys swimming in her free time.

Workers in front of computer screens

Infographic

Almost three-quarters of global business leaders believe that the green transition will create more jobs than it eliminates. Dive into our infographic to find more about the labour market impacts of the green transition.

Solar panels with workers
Blog

Charting the future of energy an interview with Dr. Angela Wilkinson

Learn how to navigate global energy transition.