Beyond the benefit:

Connecting workforce mental health and business performance

American employers do not need convincing that employee mental health matters. Eight in ten CFOs we surveyed see it as a meaningful business risk, and nearly nine in ten say it has become more important to their role over the past five years. 

Employers have reason to be concerned: workplace stress, anxiety and depression cost American businesses an estimated US$292bn a year. Many employers already invest in workforce mental health in some form, whether through health benefits, employee assistance programs or well-being tools. But our research reveals a gap between recognition, investment and results: mental health has moved on to the business agenda faster than employers’ ability to manage it. Employers may recognize the workforce risk and provide support without knowing whether it reaches the right employees or improves an intended outcome. Bringing together evidence from our CFO survey, expert interviews, evidence review and economic analysis, we examine why that gap persists—and what employers can do differently.

Four findings bring the business challenge into focus: 

1. Workplace stress, anxiety and depression cost American businesses an estimated US$292bn a year—and even that does not capture the full business burden associated with employee mental health.

Across the workforce, that is equivalent to approximately US$2,120 per employee—or more than US$10m a year for a business with 5,000 employees.

2. Nearly three-quarters of the estimated annual cost (US$214bn) shows up in healthcare, turnover and absence—areas that businesses can track—but fragmented data obscures the total impact and makes attribution difficult.

Those costs are recorded separately in claims, HR systems and leave records. The remaining US$78bn is associated with presenteeism—lost productivity that may leave no clear event or record for employers to track. 

3. Presenteeism is a blind spot—yet increased productivity is the outcome CFOs most want from employee mental health investment, and one of the hardest to measure.

Half (51%) rank increased workforce productivity and capacity among their three most important outcomes for building the business case for investment, yet around one in five (18%) do not consider workforce productivity measures when evaluating workforce investments.

4. Businesses can better assess mental health investment by tracking whether it improves intended outcomes, rather than relying on whether support is offered or used.

One in four CFOs (24%) cites a lack of measurable outcomes as a barrier to further mental health investment, while three in ten (30%) rank difficulty attributing business outcomes to specific interventions among their biggest barriers. Employers therefore need to define what an investment intends to change, how they will measure it and how that evidence will inform what happens next.

The challenge then is turning risk recognition, and even existing investment, into better results. For employers already investing, that starts with understanding what is driving the problem and where they can act. More than 40% of the estimated cost—US$121bn—is associated with workplace stress, the drivers of which include conditions employers can shape directly, such as workload, management and work design. Businesses can also influence how employees with anxiety and depression are supported at work. Matching action to the source of the problem, measuring the intended result and using the evidence to decide what comes next puts results—not provision—at the center of investment decisions. After all, behind those decisions are nearly 63m US employees experiencing workplace stress, anxiety or depression—and the productivity, skills and workforce capacity on which businesses depend to grow and stay competitive.

Beyond the benefit: Connecting workforce mental health as a business risk

Beyond the benefit: Connecting workforce mental health and business performance is a report produced by Economist Enterprise and supported by Lyra Health. It draws on: a targeted evidence review; a survey of 204 chief financial officers (CFOs) at American organizations with 500 or more employees; interviews with five experts in workplace well-being, organizational leadership and employee benefits; and a bespoke economic model. Our research puts a figure on the business cost of poor mental health and workplace stress in the US. It shows where those costs fall, where employers can do most to reduce them and how they can better focus, measure and adapt their response.

Download report

Read more from Economist Enterprise

From perk to priority

From perk to priority is a companion research initiative, produced by Economist Enterprise with support from Lyra Health, that seeks to redefine employee mental health as a business imperative through leadership and innovation.  Bridging the gap: empowering managers to lead with innovation and care report examines the challenges managers face in supporting employee mental health and explores global best practices and innovative solutions, such as advanced training and digital tools, that can help close those gaps.

Download report