What’s the score on SDG14 at half time?

Progress on the UN’s Sustainable Development Goal for the ocean has been slow so far, but hope is on the horizon

23 Jun 2023

What’s the score on SDG14 at half time?

In 2015, 193 countries committed to achieve the UN’s 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) by 2030. This year marks the half-way point—including for SDG14, Life Under Water.

SDG14 has several sub-targets which cover protecting and restoring ecosystems; making fishing sustainable and ending harmful subsidies; reducing marine pollution and ocean acidification; conserving coastal and marine areas; and increasing scientific knowledge.

The goal and its targets have raised the profile of the ocean environment. “Compared with the indifferent waters through which we were sailing before SDG14’s arrival, ocean action is now flourishing around the world,” ambassador Peter Thomson, the UN special envoy for the ocean, said at the UN General Assembly in 2021. However, he also acknowledged there was a long way to go. 

In fact, tangible action has been slower than on all other SDGs, according to the annual progress report from UN member states, which found major challenges remaining across all parts of the world.

Although the overall deadline for the SDGs is 2030, four of the targets had a deadline of 2020. These covered sustainable management and protection of marine and coastal ecosystems; effective regulation of harvesting and an end to overfishing and to illegal, unreported and unregulated (IUU) fishing; conserving at least 10% of coastal and marine areas; and ending fisheries subsidies that contribute to overfishing.

Achievement against these four targets has been “a round and inclusive failure”, according to researchers from the Universities of Plymouth and British Columbia, in a study published in the Journal of Ocean and Coastal Management.

Over the past five years, the rate of political declarations and commitments seems to have outweighed actual progress towards achieving the goals established in 2015—by a wide margin

Achievements are strongly skewed towards developed countries, says the study, with only two countries (Belgium and Germany) having achieved three of the targets. More than two-thirds of coastal states globally (107 out of 152) have not achieved a single one of the four targets with a 2020 deadline, it notes.

A lack of progress in most developing states, except island states in Oceania, may be down to a lack of investment, as well as patchy reporting and limited data, the study’s authors say. SDG14 is the least funded of all the SDGs: some US$175bn per year is needed to achieve it by 2030, according to the World Economic Forum, yet between 2015 and 2019 a total of just under US$10bn was invested.

A private-equity fund dedicated to support SDG14 was launched in March 2023 by the Prince Albert II of Monaco Foundation and Monaco Asset Management. The ReOcean Fund will provide €100m to companies with innovative plans to reduce pollution, transform ocean food production and travel, protect marine ecosystem services and provide data.

By contrast, Tom Pickerell, director of international fisheries at the Pew Trust, was less pessimistic about progress on the goals relating to reducing overfishing and IUU fishing, giving this a “B- or C+”, while acknowledging that summarising a global picture was hard as trends were very regional.

However, the key message is that stocks that are not scientifically assessed and managed were in decline, while some of those that were are starting to see a turnaround, he says. For example, tunas, sharks and billfish typically all showed decline. However, in several parts of the world tuna species are now managed by regional fisheries-management organisations, comprising the governments of all countries in the region and those from other parts of the world that fish there.

“Having management in place is really important—that sounds completely obvious, but it’s a gap in many fisheries around the world,” says Mr Pickerell.

So-called “harvest strategies” are proving successful, he adds. These use computer models to simulate how a fishery works and test potential plans against pre-agreed objectives, such as sustaining an abundant population or a high catch level. Governments need only  to negotiate the rules governing the algorithm used by the tool—once these are agreed upon, the model assigns fishing quotas to each country.

“Harvest strategies remove the politicking. They are increasingly being used, which gives me optimism, because once you have that, it’s just one argument, instead of negotiating it every year,” says Mr Pickerell.

In addition, the Ports State Measures Act—a binding international agreement to prevent IUU fish catches from being landed at ports—has now been adopted by 75 countries. Though effectiveness of implementation varies around the world, supermarkets are starting to demand that their suppliers adhere to it, according to Mr Pickerell. 

He has witnessed a shift in discussions on seafood since he started working in the sector 20 years ago. Whereas once people talked about “the inexhaustible sea” and believed that humans could take as many fish as they wanted and they would always come back, now sustainability is embedded in all discussions, he notes.

“There’s a greater understanding of the impact of fishing, that it goes beyond just what you’re fishing, such as bycatch of other species, the impact on habitats, life cycles and safety of the fishers,” Mr Pickerell says.

“We have come such a long way. We just need to translate what everyone knows needs to happen into practice,” he says.