Marine genetic resources are big business. Already, companies hold patents on thousands of products that include genes gathered through marine bioprospecting—the searching out of new biological resources that can be harvested from the ocean and turned into everything from cancer treatments to lactose-free milk. Throughout the ocean, species from deep-sea sponges to Atlantic hagfish to a bacterium—S. albidoflavus—found on land and in water around the world are studied, analysed, patented and put to use.
And because marine bioprospecting often happens on the high seas, beyond national jurisdiction, it remains somewhat underappreciated. But the High Seas Treaty—though not yet ratified—is helping to shine a spotlight on what happens far from land or deep on the ocean floor.
Erik Zhivkoplias is a PhD student at the Stockholm Resilience Center, where his focus is on the governance of the marine-biotechnology sector. He is also part of a team of researchers who, in a paper published in 2024, compiled a new database of the 92,550 protein-coding sequences associated with some 4,779 patent filings.
A former international law student who moved into computational and evolutionary biology before finding his place in marine genetic resources, Mr Zhivkoplias describes the ocean as “Earth’s oldest, most diverse laboratory”, while pointing to the huge knowledge gaps that remain in his area of study—and the knock-on effect such gaps have. “We don’t understand the price of harming deep-sea ecosystems,” he says. “When we have less than 30% of the seabed mapped, we also have much less data on the microbes and organisms that are hard to see but that play a huge role in ocean ecosystems.
“Once these ecosystems are disturbed, it is really hard to go back to the steady state they were in before,” he continues. For Mr Zhivkoplias, much rests on that gap being filled: “There are a lot of debates centred around this uncertainty,” he points out. “Can we use those resources for mineral mining or not?, for example.”
To put a figure on the value already being harvested from marine genetic resources, research points to annual sales and licensing revenues from marine drugs exceeding $1bn annually since 2011—with huge potential for further growth. Another study shows that, in 2020 alone, more than 1,400 new compounds were isolated from marine species.
Mr Zhivkoplias’s work found that just three companies—BASF, IFF and DuPont—included sequences from 949 species, a figure representing more than half of referenced species with identified marine origin.
The race to fill the gaps
At UNESCO’s Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission (IOC), various initiatives are working to ramp up data sharing. Some, like the Corporate Data Group, part of the UN Ocean Decade which is led by UNESCO-IOC, are working to persuade everyone from private actors to national governments to make public the data they gather through their normal work.
Like Mr Zhivkoplias, Peter Burger, seconded from geo-data specialist Fugro to lead the group, also points to sea-floor mapping as a key area of focus. “It’s estimated that today, another 15% to 20% of the seabed has already been mapped, but that data is locked away on servers and on hard drives—and not capitalised on,” he says.
Mr Burger points out that much of this data is with private companies and the Corporate Data Group has put significant effort into communicating why these firms should unlock this data and share it with the ocean-science community.
Stakeholder confidence is one benefit he points to when answering “What’s-in-it-for-me?” type questions: “Investors and stakeholders like to see that companies are good stewards of the ocean,” he says. Then there is the innovation that is fuelled through data sharing. “More data means more insights, more ideas, more technologies. It increases efficiency because you get a better insight into ocean currents, into what’s happening in the ocean. It makes for better operational decisions and it leads to more effective strategies for protecting the environment.”
As part of efforts to increase data sharing within the framework of the Ocean Decade, the group is now drawing up a data-sharing guideline for marine mega fauna—information that ships gather during operations but that is then left unused. “For science, that data would be very important to understand migration paths for example, or for building density maps of mammals.”
Truly global sampling
Elsewhere at UNESCO, the results of an environmental DNA (eDNA) pilot have added further to open-access data—and go towards bridging the gap between the global north and south. Almost 400 samples were taken as part of the UNESCO eDNA Expeditions pilot programme across 21 World Heritage Sites, with biodiversity data fed into the Ocean Biodiversity Information System (OBIS), which already holds information on 196,177 species.
eDNA offers an insight into ocean biodiversity without the need to extract organisms from their environment, and UNESCO says that a single litre of water can contain genetic material from hundreds of species. The method used to gather samples and deliver them to the database was also designed to be as easily replicable as possible, and simple enough that, with the right precautions to avoid contamination, student scientists could take samples that were as good as those taken by specialists
This was the case on the remote Yemeni island of Socotra—the largest in an archipelago of unique flora and fauna. Fouad Naseed Khamees, director of the Department of Research, Marine Studies and Marine Reserves/EPA Socotra, explains that the islands are vulnerable to climate change: “temperature change, irregular rainfall and hurricanes” all impact the “highly endemic” biodiversity of an archipelago that lies on the edge of the subtropical and north tropical climate belts and is home to many species that have developed in isolation.
This vulnerability to climate change was key to the eDNA pilot: biodiversity data is combined with Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change heat-scenario projections in a bid to better inform conservation decision-making. This makes it vital that sampling can be repeated and data shared—no matter how remote or challenging the site.
In typically windy Socotra conditions, Mr Khamees led more than 40 students in the island’s sampling work. “It required little effort, little cost and was very fast—and I can easily repeat it,” he says. From just seven samples taken, more than 250 species were recorded. In total, the eDNA pilot added data on thousands of species to the OBIS database.
“Any researcher, anywhere in the world, can go to our eDNA material online and exactly replicate the exercise. We feel that the same standard method across 21 countries and the open-science approach is a huge advancement,” explains Dr Fanny Douvere, head of the World Heritage Marine Programme at UNESCO, adding that the remoteness of many research stations and the isolation in which many scientists work mean there is an appetite to “join up and be certain that their method is good”.
The focus on ease and the use of common techniques and materials across countries also meant the new eDNA method was cheaper—making it even more accessible, though Dr Douvere adds that there are further tweaks to be made, such as being able to process samples locally, without the need to ship them back to UNESCO. “We applied it in Bangladesh. We applied it in Sudan. We got samples from Yemen—which was very difficult. We were in Panama and Brazil, in Argentina and Australia. With this eDNA pilot, we wanted to build a method that was applicable everywhere.”
Governance versus equity
The development of cheap sampling solutions that can be replicated anywhere, from remote research stations to war-afflicted countries, coupled with a drive to share data more openly with both scientific and local communities, relates to another challenge that Mr Zhivkoplias talks about in bioprospecting: the issue of equity and the global south.
For him, this is a question of finding a common language: “The developed world in particular looks at marine genetic resources in the context of international governance, but for representatives from the global south, the question is also about how you share the benefits that arise from the commercial use of these resources. We need to develop a shared language so that different parties can participate equally in the discussion around the value of these things,” he says.
