In the heart of urban Singapore, towers of leafy greens stretch toward the ceiling, bathed in artificial light, their exposed roots nourished by a mist of nutrient-rich vapour. These vegetables never touch soil. Nor does the sun touch them. This is the city-state’s vision of self-sufficiency: growing food upwards, not outwards.
The logic is seductive. Stack crops vertically rather than spread them across fields and you can multiply yields while shrinking your footprint. Crops are grown aeroponically, meaning they are fed with mist, or hydroponically, with roots dipped in similarly nutrient-rich water. Add sensors, AI and LEDs, and farming becomes a controlled science, not a muddy art.
Economist Enterprise’s 11th Global Food Security Index highlights how structural flaws in the global food system continue to erode food security. Its Resilience from the ground up research reveals growing urban unease; nearly two-thirds of city-dwellers surveyed have, or plan to, change their diets and food-buying habits in response to climate change. In an era of climatic upheaval and geopolitical fragility, urban self-reliance has clear appeal.
A bright idea dimmed by costs
Investors and mission-driven firms poured money into vertical-farming startups attracted by a promise that technology can help feed the planet. In 2022, the industry attracted $2.4bn in funding, but by 2024 it became clear that the industry was struggling to turn a profit, with fundraising falling to $277m, according to Pitchbook data.
Rising inflation and soaring electricity costs clipped the wings of several well-funded ventures. Plenty, a firm backed by Amazon’s Jeff Bezos, SoftBank Group and Walmart filed for bankruptcy in March. One of Britain’s biggest operators, Vertical Future, was put up for sale in July after reporting mounting losses.
“Many startups claimed they could replicate the fast-growth model of the tech world, promising explosive returns and scaling from pilot to mega-farm in a flash,” says Christine Gould, founder and CEO of GIGA, a global platform advancing innovations for nutrition and climate resilience. “But plants aren’t software—you can’t force biology to move faster or double yields overnight, no matter how clever your sensors or LED lights are.”
That biological reality is compounded by physical limits. Sunlight is free, but LED-powered photosynthesis is not. Energy accounts for 40-50% of a farm’s running costs, with most going to strips of LEDs shining light on densely packed leaves for 12 to 16 hours a day. Even with improvements in LED efficiency, the price of powering a vertical farm can be punishing, particularly when wars elsewhere cause energy prices to spike, squeezing margins even further. Cooling costs further add to the burden in hot climates.
Vertical farms may one day fare better as power grids absorb more renewable energy, making electricity not only cleaner but cheaper. To make vertical farming more viable, innovators are tinkering with everything from crop genetics to AI. Tweaks in humidity, light wavelength and nutrient mix can now be fine-tuned to each plant’s preferences. Automation also helps lower labour costs.
Lettuce isn’t lunch
Yet all this ingenuity has not solved the problem of scale. Most vertical farms produce salad leaves and microgreens, which are expensive, low-calorie crops with short shelf lives. Feeding cities requires calories, and lots of them. Experimental trials with wheat suggest it is possible to grow staples indoors, but not profitably and not at any meaningful scale. The economics remain brutal when competing with sun-drenched fields in Ukraine or Kansas.
As such, vertical farms are best viewed not as a replacement for traditional agriculture, but as a back-up system. They add redundancy to a brittle global food chain, diversify supply and grow niche crops in places where outdoor farming is impractical. Singapore, which imports more than 90% of its food, aims to produce one-third domestically by 2030, leaning on vertical farms to do it. The United Arab Emirates is investing in the technology as part of its national food-security strategy. In Shanghai, planners are designing an entire district around vertical farming to help feed the city’s 24m residents.
But even in cities the shift may be modest. “Multiple cities have local farms delivering directly to businesses or even running micro-farms in restaurants’ basements—proof that, at this scale, ‘local, fresh and consistent’ beats ‘ambitious but brittle’ megaprojects,” says Ms Gould.
From moonshot to side dish
After a spate of bankruptcies, many firms have scaled down ambitions. Plenty shuttered its leafy-green operation in California, shifting its attention to year-round strawberry production at its facility in Richmond, Virginia. Others are turning to boutique produce for high-end kitchens. The once-grand promise of planetary salvation has been replaced by more humble goals.
That may be for the best. “In hindsight, these set-ups should have been seen as advanced R&D or local specialty producers, not immediate solutions to food security at scale,” says Ms Gould. Even so, the sector’s biggest contributions, including automation, data tracking and logistics optimisation, can also be applied to greenhouses and open-air farms alike.
Smaller site-specific ventures also carry social value. Teens for Food Justice, for example, runs youth-led hydroponic farming in schools, providing fresh produce while advancing health equity. It operates seven farms in New York City and one in Denver, Colorado. Boston Medical Centre's Preventative Food Pantry initiative grows foods to supplement the treatment of some medical conditions.
Vertical farming may find its footing not as a disruptor, but as an adjunct to a more adaptive food system. In combination with other innovations, from regenerative agriculture to improved cold chains, it could help cities weather shocks, reduce waste and localise some production. Salad skyscrapers alone will not feed the future. But they may help cities take a modest bite out of the problem.
