The Food Imperative
Rethinking irrigation in a water-scarce world
The promise and perils of maximising water-use efficiency in agriculture

Expert perspectives from...
Claudia Sadoff, former executive managing director of CGIAR and board member of the Pacific Institute & Edoardo Borgomeo, associate professor of water engineering at the University of Cambridge
Mar 2025 | 3 MIN READ

Efficiency is one of the most commonly pursued—and most misunderstood—public-policy goals around the world. To mitigate climate change, we need to increase energy efficiency. To reduce supply-chain costs, we need to enhance transport efficiency. To avert a water crisis in a world where some 70% of freshwater withdrawals is used in agriculture, we need greater irrigation efficiency.
Yet cutting costs and resources, or overhauling seemingly inefficient systems often does not improve outcomes: rather than improving the system targeted, efficiency measures can undermine their resilience and ability to deliver services.
Why does this matter to our food systems? With rising water scarcity and human impacts on freshwater ecosystems, increasing and sustaining food production while limiting water use is an urgent challenge. A fundamental response to this challenge will be more efficient irrigation technologies that maintain or increase agricultural output for the same or reduced water input at the field level, thus improving the “crop per drop” ratio (ie, the amount of water that goes into actually growing crops rather than being lost in conveyance, irrigating weeds or evaporating). Compared with traditional irrigation approaches where water is distributed over the field by overland flow—broadly referred to as surface irrigation— efficient irrigation technologies such as drip systems use pressurised systems to allow water to drip slowly to the roots of plants through narrow tubes equipped with emitters. Drip-irrigation technology typically ensures that around 85 to 95% of the water taken from a source reaches the crop, as opposed to much lower efficiencies for surface-water systems. These efficiency improvements are particularly attractive in arid areas from the American West to northern Chile, and from north-west India to Morocco.
Policymakers hope that the introduction of high-tech irrigation will save water in agriculture, “releasing” it for other users and for ecosystem sustainability. However, as a growing body of evidence points out, high-tech irrigation on its own rarely leads to the desired water savings. In fact, as the Jevons paradox cautioned, it appears to lead to the opposite effect: farmers equipped with high-tech irrigation technology use more, not less, water, and water availability across river basins tends to decline. Researchers call this the “paradox of irrigation efficiency”. Some farmers use the “saved” water to expand irrigated area (with consequent land conversion and habitat loss), others increase their cropping intensity (growing more crops in a given year on the same field), or grow more water-intensive crops (shifting from sorghum to rice). More efficient application of water at the farm level also reduces return flows—the water that runs off the field or percolates into the ground after application, and which finds its way into rivers and aquifers and is therefore available for downstream users and ecosystems.
The paradox of irrigation efficiency is particularly dangerous in a water-scarce world for a number of reasons. First, it can undermine the resilience of freshwater ecosystems. As return flows diminish, less water is available to flow downstream to help fish breed and move, boost bird breeding or support wetlands. Second, changing the patterns of water availability can disrupt the livelihoods of other users dependent on the same resource. Finally, efficient technologies enable farmers to shift to water-intensive crops, so that when the next drought comes— because drought always comes—the damage is even greater. Rather than promoting adaptation to dry and water-scarce conditions, these technologies might paradoxically encourage “maladaptation” by leading farmers to move away from drought-resistant crops and thus increase their vulnerability to future, longer droughts.
To reduce water use in agriculture, we need more than just high-tech efficient irrigation technologies. Irrigation efficiency through technology alone is false efficiency. Global experience shows that investing in drip-irrigation systems only “saves” water if it is bundled with other interventions, such as limits on water extractions (water “caps”) and improved monitoring of water resources. When a shift to more efficient irrigation technology is accompanied by strict limits and control of extraction and pumping for irrigation, it can help to curb further increases in water consumption. And when improved data and monitoring are used to track stocks, flows and uses of water through the agriculture system—something called water accounting—we can have much better quantification of the impact of interventions on water consumption. Water accounting requires reversing the decline of on-the-ground monitoring stations and leveraging the potential of advances in earth observation and machine learning.
In the end, capturing the benefits of irrigation efficiency will require aligned technological, institutional and political interventions all at the same time. It will also call for rethinking irrigation in the context of water scarcity: moving from seeing irrigation efficiency as something to be achieved through technology alone, to seeing it as something that can only be realised by balancing technology with water monitoring and regulation and a greater understanding of farmers’ needs and behaviours.
Author bios
Claudia Sadoff, former executive managing director of CGIAR and board member of the Pacific Institute
Claudia Sadoff has served as Executive Managing Director of CGIAR, the world’s largest non-profit partnership of food, land, and water systems research institutes; Director General of the International Water Management Institute (IWMI); and the World Bank’s Global Lead for Water Security and Water Resources Management. She has been recognized with appointments including Distinguished Visiting Scholar at Oxford University, Honorary Member of the International Water Resources Association and Fulbright Scholar. She holds a PhD in Economics from the University of California, Berkeley.
Edoardo Borgomeo, associate professor of Water Engineering at the University of Cambridge
Edoardo Borgomeo is Associate Professor of Water Engineering at the University of Cambridge. Prior to joining Cambridge, Edoardo served as a water resources management specialist at the World Bank, as a water specialist at the Food and Agricultural Organization of the United Nations in Rome and as an advisor at the International Water Management Institute in Sri Lanka. Edoardo holds an undergraduate degree in earth science and engineering from Imperial College London and a doctorate in water resources management from the University of Oxford.
Views or opinions expressed are those of the author and any individuals cited, and do not necessarily reflect those of Economist Enterprise or any other member of The Economist Group.