Q&A with Amy Brachio, EY global vice chair of sustainability

No one solution will accelerate action on climate change. It requires whole-economy transformation with multi-year public and private investments.

Amy Brachio
Amy Brachio
EY global vice-chair—sustainability

12 Mar 2025

Q&A with Amy Brachio, EY global vice chair of sustainability

In light of concerns about slowing momentum to sustainability goals in the past year, who is driving companies to push forward on sustainability? Customers, shareholders, leadership or other stakeholders? Do you think the concerns about a slowdown are legitimate?

Despite recent geopolitical and economic headwinds, international policy, regulatory pressure and stakeholder scrutiny have all played a part in maintaining momentum on the integration of sustainability goals into business and society.

That said, while the aggregate impact of business action has huge potential, progress is currently negligible compared to what is needed. EY research shows that fewer than half (41%) of large companies worldwide have published a transition plan for climate-change mitigation even as global temperatures hit new highs. 

As the economic risks associated with climate change become more apparent, along with the scale of private sector investment required, business is aware of the critical role it must play. However, there’s a risk that headlines about policy differences distract from the complexity of what we are dealing with. No one agreement or solution will accelerate climate action. It requires whole-economy transformation with multi-year public and private investments across industry, transport, skills and infrastructure. To ensure this, the nationally determined contributions (NDCs) due in 2025 need to set a ten-year framework to make long-term targets practical, investable and achievable for business in the near term. 

From investors we are also seeing fatigue in quantifying the long-term value of ESG benefits in investment outcomes, leading to prioritisation of short-term financial performance. However, they continue to engage meaningfully with sustainability, understanding the economic and social disruption posed by climate risks, particularly with an inter-generational wealth shift under way bringing a generation of more sustainability-motivated asset owners, conscious of sustainability outcomes alongside financial returns. 

You've previously mentioned the need to reframe the discussion around climate action to be about long-term business risk. Can you explain/elaborate?

The scale of risk or opportunity linked to climate and nature will be proportionate to how a business plans and invests for transformation in the coming months, not in ten years’ time when the risks could be exponentially greater. To note, WEF’s latest global risk analysis reveals environmental risks are four of the top five risks identified in the long term to 2035.

The list of risks that businesses face has expanded over time, with the climate crisis posing a range of policy, regulation, reputational, social and physical risks. It’s therefore critical that sustainability is approached through a lens of risk management and value creation. Updated reporting and robust risk management practices to address issues ranging from regulatory demands to geopolitical volatility are crucial, too. Additionally, businesses must consider the physical risks that climate change poses to infrastructure, people and supply chains.

To bridge the gap between ambition and real action, businesses must balance short-term uncertainty and long-term risk, integrating both considerations into internal governance and reporting.

Focusing on short-term risks linked to macroeconomic and geopolitical shifts and allowing election outcomes to dictate climate strategies is a mistake. Business leaders must reframe climate action and take immediate actions to mitigate long-term risk.

People are at the core of any sustainable transition. What is the role of green skilling and education, and how can we ensure that a transition is just and benefits wide swathes of society?

Green skilling and education play crucial roles in ensuring a just and inclusive transition, yet we are far from having the green talent, skills and jobs required to complete a green transformation. This is despite the fact that the green transition is one of the major forces reshaping the labor market, with climate change adaptation and mitigation expected to contribute a net growth of 78 million jobs. 

To say that green skills are in short supply is an understatement. We urgently need to address the integration of policies and programmes to support green skills development, along with the lack of investment in education and training, exacerbated by the current difficult economic climate. 

Right now, organisations need a workforce with a broad range of technical and knowledge-related skills to effectively deliver on their sustainability strategies. This could include anything from employing climate and energy transition experts to embedding green skills throughout the business at all levels so that sustainability awareness delivers day to day on resource efficiency, supply chain and improved resilience.

Countries must also ensure that existing social inequities are not worsened by green initiatives, particularly for workers in carbon-intensive industries who may be left behind as organisations transition to new approaches, products and processes.

In light of the most recent biodiversity COP in Cali, how do you see the intersection of climate concerns, nature and biodiversity?

I recently spoke with my colleague Dr Velislava Ivanova, EY Americas chief sustainability officer, on this topic and she raised an interesting point that while some businesses around the world treat nature and biodiversity as novel topics, many of the largest companies already have initiatives in place to protect them. This is because they understand that, ultimately, when we’re talking about biodiversity and nature, we’re talking about resources, the reliance on which are fundamental to business survival.

A recent report by the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services (IPBES) reveals $25 trillion, equivalent to one-quarter of global GDP, is lost annually as a result of businesses’ not accounting for their environmental impact. The challenge we face here is that climate change, nature and biodiversity are issues too often tackled in isolation.

Businesses must understand the link between biodiversity preservation and business value as well as the interconnectedness of the climate, nature and biodiversity crises, and the need to address these as a whole when integrating into business models.

 2024 was a big year for politics. How do you see political trends affecting sustainability policy and its stability?

We are operating at an incredibly complex time for the public and private sectors in terms of economics, geopolitics and the climate risk. 

The reality is, concerns around inflation, employment opportunities, national security, energy security, and energy costs are shifting priorities. Governments are therefore being challenged by citizens to stabilise short-term economic outcomes and cost-of-living pressures, and businesses want simplification of regulation.

While companies aren’t divorced from this pressure, they can take a step back and say, “For our business and sector, what are the practical investments and actions we need to take now that ensure we’re fit for future growth, markets and regulation?”

For business, it’s rightly reinforcing the need for sustainability policy that supports projects and initiatives that deliver value in the near term, as well as laying the foundations for long-term product and market transformation. Policies and incentives supporting early adoption and market development of EVs, renewables for example, may evolve in markets where they are now established, and shift to accelerating other solutions like AI, and circular economy or waste issues, to engage with consumers and business. These approaches can support more efficient ways of working, innovation and market transformation, while also supporting wider economic growth.

Finally, while the uncertainty of many elections last year caused both government and business to reflect on priorities, so too will the extreme weather events in 2024 and early 2025. The human, physical and supply chain impacts for companies and countries will impact how governments consider risk and resilience. 

What are your thoughts on the role of AI in driving sustainability, keeping in mind its major appetite for energy and role in growing power demand?

Data and technology can transform how we understand, plan and act on climate change, as well as accelerate the development of insights and solutions. However, that needs to be balanced with addressing AI’s energy intensity. 

Digital enablement is key to accelerating progress towards a more sustainable future. A top-down AI strategy aligned with business and sustainability goals enables organisations to make data-driven decisions to lower their environmental impact, optimise resource usage, reduce waste and manage risks more effectively. For example, in the telecoms industry, AI-driven initiatives have demonstrated potential energy savings of 10% to 40% in various network operations, contributing to reduced greenhouse gas emissions.

EY is championing the use of AI to drive more intelligent, data-informed decisions too. The EY Open Science Data Challenge was established in 2021 to offer an open-access platform to enable participants to use cutting-edge technologies, satellite data and AI to create models that address a diverse range of global sustainability issues. 

In 2025 we’re calling for innovators to use AI to predict city temperatures and aid urban design to address urban heat islands, enhancing the wellbeing of city-dwellers as well as mitigating the energy intensive demands of cooling.

Where do you see the biggest opportunity for progress in 2025?

In short—technology, simplification and standardisation. Reporting and measurement have evolved significantly and increased the relevance and understanding of sustainability in business. Technology has enabled it, and through AI there is huge potential to accelerate that further. Recent announcements regarding the expansion of ISSB and how the EU are looking at the potential of simplifying reporting regulation should be taken as a signal by companies to turn from data gathering to integration, to inform transformation, decision making and investment.

With increasing global regulatory demands on sustainability reporting, what are the primary challenges that corporations face in maintaining transparency while also protecting competitive interests?

Global standards and reporting frameworks can drive business transformation, extracting valuable data and helping key decision makers better understand the intricacies of their organisation. Collectively, this can provide the private sector with an opportunity to go further, faster, together.

However, in the face of more stringent regulatory demands on sustainability reporting, there were some initial concerns that increased transparency could stifle competitive advantages and advancements in terms of innovation. 

There was also a perception that companies may view regulatory frameworks as a compliance issue, a box to check, and only meet the minimum regulatory requirements rather than look to take full accountability for their environmental footprint.

Additionally, despite best efforts, many seemed to be unprepared for the extensive requirements of directives like the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD). 

This creates an opportunity to maintain high levels of commitment and ambition and channel innovations towards meeting sustainability goals. This in turn can drive business value and resilience through enhanced efficiency and a more robust supply chain—thereby garnering a competitive advantage.

Regulatory requirements, while challenging, move sustainability from the periphery into core business considerations, driving development and therefore enhancing competitiveness and long-term success.

Companies are under pressure to go beyond pledges and operationalise sustainability goals. What obstacles do you see as most significant in moving from sustainability commitments to real-world outcomes?

There are two key elements—systemic challenges and company-specific challenges. We are past the ‘quick win’ phase of energy efficiency and are now facing a multi-decade whole-economy transformation. This takes time and investment when both are under pressure for results. 

How companies are embedding decisions and commitments is challenging. EY recently interviewed board members from six companies on the role of sustainability, with one interviewee articulating that the obstacle many CSOs face, “is translating concepts and value into business language, because that's what the CFO speaks.” 

Businesses need to break down silos and ensure strategy discussions and metrics account for social and economic impact—as well as making sure the data is getting to the right people. 

The relationship between CFO and CSO is also key. Each of the roles must understand the lens the other applies to sustainability and how they define success. It means listening to sometimes differing views while on the path to achieve the same goals. That’s what can translate relevance and opportunities into information and action that will inform strategy and operations, and therefore progress. 

There are five key areas that can shape the focus: 

  1. Get to grips with how technology can support you.

  2. Rethink business models, including how you work in your supply chain and engage with local communities.

  3. Consider how you can reframe time horizons and return on investment, developing a clear roadmap with longer-term perspectives linked to your purpose.

  4. Expand your ecosystem because no one company can solve this alone. Work with others, including competitors. 

  5. Think about the implications of governance. Get comfortable dealing with representative stakeholder groups to give the full range of voices a seat at the table.

 Scope 3 emissions are a major challenge. Are there specific examples of innovative approaches to managing Scope 3 and coordinating across value chains that have shown promise in this area?

For a people-oriented business like EY, there are real ways of navigating Scope 3 challenges. Historically air travel accounted for a large proportion of our global carbon emissions—approximately 75% in FY19. 

While many EY services require an element of business travel, we have taken significant measures to reduce our travel-related emissions by 35% per employee by 2025.

Achieving this reduction will avoid emitting over 2m tonnes of CO2 from FY19 to FY25. Additionally, we’re working closely with airline and hospitality clients to find innovative solutions to create lasting change to our routines that were previously status quo.

As a global company with more than 700 offices in more than 150 countries, we have launched an internal effort to address our energy intensity and transition to renewable sources.

Currently, 47% of our electricity globally comes from renewable sources, including 100% renewable energy supply in the UK, US, Canada and Germany, and significant proportions in India, Japan as well as a number of countries across South America.

That is all to say, innovative approaches will be relative to the industries and markets in which a company operates. For EY that meant tackling travel and energy—two vital aspects of our operations. 

Views or opinions expressed are those of the author and any individuals cited, and do not necessarily reflect those of Economist Enterprise or any other member of The Economist Group.