Prioritising innovation: the case against the carbon tax

A guest op-ed from Ben Ho, professor of economics at Vassar College and former lead energy economist for the White House Council of Economic Advisers

Ben Ho
Ben Ho
Professor of economics at Vassar College and former lead energy economist for the White House Council of Economic Advisers

17 Nov 2022

carbon tax

This piece is part of the series “Reimagining economics for a carbon-constrained world”. It argues that subsidies and other policy incentives are more effective than carbon taxes at driving the technological innovation needed to meet climate goals.

The views expressed in the blog are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Economist Enterprise or the sponsor.

Explore another side of the debate with Ian Parry, principal environmental fiscal policy expert in the International Monetary Fund’s Fiscal Affairs Department, who argues that carbon taxes are critical for reducing greenhouse-gas emissions at pace. Read his take here.

Would carbon taxes help hold polluting companies accountable? Read the explainer article here.

It is time to give up on the carbon tax. Putting a price on carbon has not been popular with the public (although a 2021 global poll indicated increasing support), and few politicians are eager to attach their name to a policy with the word “tax” in it. I, like many economists, have been a long-time supporter of carbon taxes. But there are two important reasons for a rethink.

Focusing on market failures

First, major advances in solar, wind and electric-vehicle technologies have radically reshaped the policy environment over the past ten years in ways that many have been slow to recognise. Second, while carbon taxes are part of the optimal portfolio of policies to fight climate change, they are not the most important part. We can better target policies to fight climate change by identifying underlying market failures that make climate change a problem. These are:

  1. Firms and consumers generally don’t pay for the damage caused by the greenhouse gases they emit.

  2. Those who innovate are generally undercompensated for the value of what they create.

  3. Existing infrastructure is designed around a fossil-fuel energy system.

Each of these three failures constitutes a different externality. The problem with carbon taxes is that they address only the first. Economists like the idea of a carbon tax because it forces firms and consumers to pay for the damage they cause, creating incentives for them to seek out more eco-friendly alternatives. While shifting consumption is good, innovation, when it works, is better. The benefits of innovation can spread to others across the globe and create lasting change that does not need perpetual government regulation to maintain. While carbon taxes can encourage innovation, policies like prizes, research grants and subsidies do more to prioritise it.

New technologies will require new grid and charging infrastructure, which only become viable when enough people make the switch. Subsidies can move the economy over that hump. Markets will then take care of the rest.

Subsidising the solutions

One common critique of subsidies is that they involve bureaucrats or legislators making guesses about which innovations will matter when they decide how to spend taxpayer money. Advocates of a carbon tax believe that it is better to tax what you know to be bad, rather than subsidise what you think might one day be good. You never know where innovation might come from. Case in point: the world has spent billions of dollars each year subsidising technologies like nuclear and ethanol fuel, with the hope that they could one day replace fossil fuels, to no avail. 

Spurred on by a mix of pre-existing carbon-pricing policies, renewable-electricity mandates, government grants and tax subsidies in the US and around the world, renewables are now cheaper than fossil fuels. At the same time, innovation in electric-powered engines and battery technologies makes electric cars increasingly cost-competitive with conventional ones. It is easy to pick winners when you already know who won.

Markets chase lower costs. Forcing them to adopt higher-cost renewable technology is like pushing a boulder up a hill. It requires taxes and heavy-handed regulation. But now that renewables are getting cheaper, we just need to get that boulder over the transition-cost hump. New technologies will require new grid and charging infrastructure, which only become viable when enough people make the switch. Subsidies can move the economy over that hump. Markets will then take care of the rest.

Many believe carbon taxes are more efficient than subsidies because subsidies must still be paid for via taxes. But that efficiency presumes that governments use carbon-tax revenues effectively. It is not only unclear what counts as “effective”—economists’ preferred idea of returning money to people via a dividend has not proved popular with US voters. Many also fear that revenues would be spent on things they care little about or actively resist. Furthermore, a case can be made that increasing income taxes (which primarily fall on the relatively well-off) to pay for subsidies is better than a carbon tax, which is paid by everybody, even if a carbon tax is ostensibly more efficient.

Finally, the efficiency case for the carbon tax rests on the assumption that energy markets are otherwise operating efficiently. But joint research from UC Berkeley and the University of Chicago has found that because energy markets are often mispriced (because of technological limitations and a mess of regulations) carbon taxes can indeed be less efficient than other policies.

An international perspective

Perhaps the most important benefit of a climate policy focused on innovation is its ability to spread to the developing world. Most emissions going forward are expected to come from places like China, India and Africa.

It took just 12 years for most of the world to get a smartphone, because people saw the inherent value in personal mobile-communications technology. Innovative, lower-cost renewable-power technologies can follow the same path. It is likely far easier to convince voters in developing countries to adopt money-saving technologies than it is to convince them to support a costly carbon tax.

If I could turn back time to the Industrial Revolution—when historical greenhouse gases began to surge—a carbon tax would undoubtedly be the centrepiece of my climate agenda. But we do not live that world. Existing regulations, carbon prices and subsidies have already done a lot of the work towards achieving the innovation we need to meet global environmental goals. In that world—our world—a focus on innovation and infrastructure are the policies with the highest chance of success.

Reimagining economics in a carbon constrained world

Explore a series of articles and op-eds bringing the biggest debates on the role of sustainability in business and economic growth to life.

Discover more
sap reimagining economics

RELATED ARTICLES

Start of carousel.

carbon pollution
Supported by SAP
Circular Economies

Holding polluting sectors accountable for the climate crisis

What does corporate climate responsibility look like?

Meeting
from SAP
Circular Economies

Prioritising people: human capital moves to the core of responsible, sustainable business strategies

As value chains become more complex, companies must expand their people responsibilities to a broader ecosystem of stakeholders and empower all parts of the business to promote social and economic well-being

Advertisement feature
Lady with a bag
from SAP
Circular Economies

Turning talk into action: retail’s path to sustainability

To match rhetoric with tangible progress on sustainability, the sector needs to embrace new materials and technologies, while engaging with consumers and collaborating with industry peers

Advertisement feature
sap-hero-image-blog-michael-jakob
Supported by SAP
Circular Economies

Smart growth can help achieve a good life for all without killing the planet

A guest op-ed from Michael Jakob, senior fellow at the Ecologic Institute

sap-hero-image-blog-susan-paulson
Supported by SAP
Circular Economies

Economic growth will continue to provoke climate change

A guest op-ed from Susan Paulson, professor at the Centre for Latin American Studies, University of Florida, and co-author, “The Case for Degrowth”

SAP-Economist-Impact-Article-2-Hero-Banner_optimized
Supported by SAP
Circular Economies

Economic growth at all costs: what is the trade-off?

Bring up “economic growth” in nearly any forum—academic conference, policymaker debate, business roundtable—and everyone will spout ideas about how to spark it, maximise it and make it endure

Workers in a waste plant
from SAP
Circular Economies

Winning the battle against waste is a global imperative—and a regenerative business opportunity

Businesses are key players in reducing global waste. By embracing circularity, companies can be at the forefront of action and harness significant market opportunities.

Advertisement feature
Hero-SAP-Blog-Kaplan-v.2
Supported by SAP
Circular Economies

Milton Friedman’s wisdom endures: companies should be run for shareholders

A guest op-ed from Steve Kaplan, professor of entrepreneurship and finance at the University of Chicago Booth School of Business

Mariana-Blog-Hero-v3
Supported by SAP
Circular Economies

Moving beyond the rhetoric of purpose and building a truly multi-stakeholder approach

A guest op-ed from Mariana Mazzucato, professor in the economics of innovation and public value at University College London

SAP Article 1 hero
from SAP
Circular Economies

A new playbook for sustainable business

The sustainability landscape has been transformed in recent years. Investors are increasingly focused on the social and environmental performance of the assets in their portfolios.

Advertisement feature
Hero Article 1 EI
Supported by SAP
Net Zero & Energy

Shareholder primacy versus stakeholderism: a false dichotomy?

The dominant economic philosophies for companies are not mutually exclusive

End of carousel.