
This year the UN World Tourism Organisation (UNWTO) expects visitor numbers to return to those seen before the pandemic. Tourist arrivals reached 80% of pre-covid levels in the first quarter of 2023, with an estimated 235m tourists travelling internationally during that time. That figure is more than double the same period in 2022.
The travel industry is unprepared to cope with the swell in vacationers, charges the UNWTO. Compelled by the cash the rebound brings, the aggressive bounce-back in travel is driving “overtourism”—a term in the travel industry’s lexicon to describe the consequences of having too many visitors.
“There has been an overreaction in terms of travel after people were deprived for three years under the pandemic,” says Zoritsa Urosevic, UNWTO’s executive director. “We hope that this is going to subside,” she adds, noting that both the UNWTO and the tourism industry were surprised by the rapid recovery in tourist numbers.
Not designed for tourism
Overtourism occurs when a destination cannot cope with the numbers of visitors it receives, explains Ross Bennett-Cook, a tourism researcher and visiting lecturer at London’s Westminster University.
“There’s definitely a difference between mass tourism and overtourism,” he says. “Overtourism is more likely to affect destinations that weren’t necessarily designed for tourism: Venice, Dubrovnik, Barcelona. Then there are places like Benidorm and Magaluf that receive masses of visitors, but because they were built for tourism they are prepared for it.”
There is no official threshold that indicates a destination has reached capacity. Ms Urosevic says overtourism is a term the UNWTO avoids, while Jonathan Tourtellot of the Destination Stewardship Centre says it puts a name to a phenomenon that was a problem long before the term was coined.
Mr Tourtellot says the industry should have predicted the return of mass travel, despite the high ambitions during lockdown. “The pandemic provoked a lot of rethinking. But the instinct for every tourism minister, every destination marketing organisation, is to go for more—particularly when they’re under pressure to show recovery from the pandemic,” says Mr Tourtellot.
But such overcrowding brings costs which are borne by local residents. Citydwellers find that pavements, roads and cycle lanes are clogged. In party towns, like Amsterdam and Prague, residents must put up with late-night hooliganism. Island resorts suffer from litter-strewn beaches and polluted water. In 2018 President Rodrigo Duterte of the Philippines banned tourists from the popular island of Boracay for six months, because too many visitors and too few sewers had made it a “cesspool”.
Overtourism oversight
Honeypot sites—from Thailand to Italy’s Venice—are beginning to investigate ways to crack down on overcrowding, home-sharing websites and antisocial behaviour.
The Spanish city of Barcelona has introduced some measures to mitigate overtourism, such as a hike in its tourist tax, the creation of “super blocs” that move traffic outside of residential streets, and the introduction of one-way systems at the city’s most popular attractions.
Barcelona’s city council has also been trying to reduce the number of cruise ships arriving and disgorging thousands of tourists into the streets. However, pushback from the port authority saw the city receive 805 cruise liners last year—more than in 2019.
“If you want to go to the core of the problem, it is the fact that in most cases nobody is really in charge,” says Mr Tourtellot. “Also, different parts of government may be at odds with each other: the environmental department and the economic development department could be at loggerheads, [and] the port authority might encourage more cruise ships, for example.”
Locals complain of being outnumbered. According to Barcelona’s governing Generalitat, 60% of residents think their city has reached capacity, while the most popular districts of Ciutat Vella and Gràcia want fewer tourists.
Amsterdam is the latest to take aim at cruise ships. In July it took a first step towards banning large cruise liners under broader plans to reduce mass tourism and pollution. The European Federation for Transport and Environment said in June that 63 cruise ships owned by the Carnival Corporation emitted 43% more sulphur oxides than Europe’s 291m cars in 2022. Other major European cities including Dubrovnik and Venice have made similar moves to restrict the vessels.
A form of neo-colonialism
The negative impact of cruise tourism is something Mr Bennett-Cook raises too, highlighting the huge—and often overlooked—impact of these megaships.
“Where you see the biggest issues with coastal damage is often those destinations that rely so heavily on tourism—the Caribbean, for example,” he says. “It's hard for them to restrict [tourism] because they need the money that comes with that.” In Antigua and Barbuda for example, tourism accounted for some 48 per cent of GDP in 2019, according to Caribbean Development Bank data.
Speaking as Royal Caribbean announced a massive new ship, Icon of the Seas, set to debut in January with space for 5,600 guests and 2,350 crew members, Mr Bennett-Cook questioned the lack of scrutiny around such vessels.
“Why are we allowing ships to get bigger and bigger?” he asks. “It is impossible for a 7,000-plus-person cruise ship to be environmentally friendly, or sustainable.”
He says the rapidly growing tourism segment is even seen as “a kind of neocolonialism” by some, particularly in developing countries in the Caribbean, “where these destinations now rely so heavily on the West for tourism, with limited control of their own resources.”
“The industry uses the benefits of the country—uses the weather to sell the holiday—but the actual destination itself receives very limited benefits from it,” he says.
People, planet and prosperity
Overtourism regularly makes news headlines as once Instagram-perfect beaches—such as Maya Beach in Thailand of “The Beach” fame—are shut down, or number-plate rules are brought in to ease traffic on the glamorous Amalfi Coast. But what about broader, long-term efforts?
Mr Tourtellot advocates establishing destination stewardship councils charged with looking at the intersection between tourism and care for the destination, including advising the government and businesses, taking care of nature and culture, and considering the history of the place.
“These councils work best if they’re made up of equal parts government, private sector—preferably enlightened private sector—and civil society,” he says, adding that this “three-legged approach” means the council can survive changes in government. “We have seen many good intentions get thrown out when the government changes,” he says. “The council has to be able to survive.”
For Ms Urosevic and UNWTO, data and measurement are at the core of improving management. The organisation is working with the University of Oxford’s Sustainable Development Goals Impact Lab—and with low-cost airline EasyJet—to develop environmental, social and governance measures for the industry.
“What we don’t have today is comparable frameworks to measure the impact of tourism,” says Ms Urosevic. “We are looking at plastic pollution in the ocean, at the availability of drinking water, at the happiness of locals.” The balance between income generation on the one hand and space and social indicators on the other remains the most difficult to define.
MORE FROM TOURISM
Our editorial explores the issue of “overtourism” – the role of policy in alleviating the overcrowding caused by an excess of tourists and the ways in which the travel industry can spur the protection and preservation of natural spaces. With much work still to do to achieve SDG 14 (on ocean sustainability), how can we find ways to grow this important ocean industry in sustainable and responsible ways?
Start of carousel.

Sustainable tourism management in the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park: a collective effort
A guest blog by Josh Thomas – CEO, Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority

Covid changed the DNA of tourism”: Destinations look generations ahead following pandemic rethink
Sustainability, stewardship and generative tourism are key buzzwords as elements of the industry shift from a focus on numbers

Overtourism: coastal management key as global traveller numbers return to pre-pandemic levels
More people are travelling, and many are visiting the same locations. The UN World Tourism Organisation says the travel industry has been caught unprepared as millions flock to hotspots.

Balancing profit and planet in the ocean tourism industry
A guest blog by Giulio Magni, director of One Ocean Foundation

Regenerative coastal tourism: protecting the planet through unforgettable experiences
Speakers at the 10th annual World Ocean Summit highlighted the planet-saving power and profitability of regenerative blue tourism

Will tourism recover from the Covid-19 crisis sustainably?
The World Ocean Summit heard about the sector’s pathways towards environmental sustainability.

Preserving the ocean with regenerative tourism
A guest blog by Hemal Jain, general manager, and Silvina Miguel, regenerative tourism consultant and permaculture designer, Alila Villas Uluwatu

Creating a better planet through better tourism
A blog by Luís Araújo, president of Turismo de Portugal and speaker at the upcoming World Ocean Summit

Can a holiday help deliver on global goals?
Adopting patterns of sustainable consumption and production in the tourism industry can benefit people and the planet.

Restoring coral reefs through regenerative tourism
Catching up with Ocean Changemaker Challenge winner Olga Lucía Caro Jácome
End of carousel.