Now is the time to protect Africa’s most biodiverse ocean region from exploitation

By Dr Samantha Petersen, WWF-SWIO regional programme lead

Dr Samantha Petersen
Dr Samantha Petersen
Lead for the WWF South-West Indian Ocean Regional Programme

11 Nov 2024

Now is the time to protect Africa’s most biodiverse ocean region from exploitation

WWF defines a sustainable ocean-based or "blue" economy as one that provides social and economic benefits for current and future generations; restores, protects and maintains diverse, productive and resilient marine ecosystems; and is based on clean technologies, renewable energy and circular material flows.

The South-West Indian Ocean (SWIO)—the second-most biodiverse ocean region in the world and an area of great natural beauty—is at a crossroads. 

One road leads to shared prosperity based on the value that nature currently delivers to the approximately 10m people who live along the coastlines of Mozambique, Kenya, Tanzania, Madagascar and South Africa. The other road leads to an economy dominated by international markets that are channelling billions of dollars towards exploiting the region’s blue economy.

This is the key finding of a recently published WWF report that highlights that 70% of the US$20.17bn in loans targeted to the SWIO region as of August 2023 were channelled towards the energy and resources sector. Similarly, 78% of the $7bn in investments into the region between 2017 and 2023 went towards energy. In both cases, the finance flowed mostly to oil and gas extraction. By contrast, only 1% of total loans and investments went to fishing and aquaculture. The remaining finance was directed towards marine shipping and infrastructure.

The report goes on to make two further important observations. 

First, it notes that most of the loans and investments in the SWIO region come from financial institutions in developed countries, specifically the United States, France, the United Kingdom, Norway and Germany. China, too, plays a prominent role in financing the region’s blue economy.

The exception to this is South Africa which, though a developing country, is also a leading financier of blue activities in the region. However, most of the loans and investments originating in South Africa remain within the country.

Second, the report notes that financial institutions active in the region (and the national financial regulations that oversee local investments and loans) tend to have a blind spot when it comes to assessing and limiting the externalised risks involved with blue-economy financing. This observation is based on assessments of national financial regulations and the ESG (environment, social and governance) policies of 25 commercial banks and institutional investors active in the region.

Top investor countriesCorrections in the graphic: The USA is by far the greatest investor in the region and almost all its investments go to oil, gas and mining UK (no full point)

The combination of large financial flows from predominantly foreign sources and a lack of sound ESG policies and regulations to manage the risks associated with business-as-usual (BAU) activities paints the picture of a region that is heading for a destructive modern-day “gold rush” powered by internationally derived finance. 

This BAU approach is leading to the overexploitation of the blue economy, which is concerning at the global level because our oceans are important carbon sinks and critical to humanity’s efforts to mitigate climate change. 

At the local level, financing destructive BAU practices (while sustainable-development pathways and conservation efforts struggle to attract funding) is jeopardising the resilience of the SWIO region’s already underdeveloped coastal communities, who depend heavily on healthy ocean ecosystems for their food and livelihoods. Key marine habitats like coral reefs and mangroves—which are already impacted by unprecedented and unsustainable coastal development—protect these communities against sea-level rise and storm surges linked to climate change, while providing safe spawning grounds for fish stocks.

WWF graph 2Corrections in the graphic: Top creditor countries UK

What can we do about it?

Every dollar directed towards over-extracting the region’s ocean resources increases the risk that important coastal ecosystems will be damaged. This will have severe long-term repercussions for both the planet and the region’s coastal communities. 

We urgently need to redirect existing financial flows towards activities that will protect and restore our ocean ecosystems for the benefit of people and nature. To this end, WWF urges banks, investors and regulators to sign up to the UNEP Finance Initiative’s Sustainable Blue Economy Finance Principles. These 14 principles—which were co-developed by WWF—provide guidance on how to integrate currently externalised ecological and societal risks into decision-making processes in a transparent, equitable and science-led way. 

Globally, everyday investors are demanding meaningful “green” and “impact” investment options. Through its on-the-ground efforts to establish sustainable blue enterprises and value chains, WWF is working to place SWIO on the map as an investment destination that offers such options, with a focus on coastal communities who currently have limited opportunities to develop in a sustainable way. This will be further complemented by regional efforts to bridge the gap between “development enterprise” and “investment readiness” through the SWIO Venture Builder. 

In this way, WWF will keep applying persistent pressure at strategic leverage points until the SWIO region is on the path towards a blue economy that is sustainable, inclusive and resilient.

Views or opinions expressed are those of the author and any individuals cited, and do not necessarily reflect those of Economist Enterprise or any other member of The Economist Group.

Header image: Unsplash