Multilateral success but no back-patting come 2030: IOC/UNESCO executive secretary talks SDGs

Vidar Helgesen points to progress at a “very difficult time for multilateralism”, but describes the overall picture for the ocean and SDGs as “grim”

Vidar Helgesen
Vidar Helgesen
Executive Secretary of the Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission (IOC/UNESCO) and Assistant Director-General of UNESCO

14 Jan 2025

Vidar Helgesen Q&A hero

The start of 2025 is a key checking-in point for the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Part of the UN 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, which also includes 169 associated targets, few if any of the 17 SDGs set back in 2015 have made the kind of progress hoped for at the time. And SDG 14—Life below water—is often described as the least funded of all. 

We spoke to Vidar Helgesen, executive secretary of the Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission and assistant director-general of UNESCO, about what this means for the ocean and the UN goals, where progress has been made, and where Mr Helgesen and IOC/UNESCO want to shine the development spotlight as we edge closer to 2030. 

An international lawyer by training, Helgesen was previously Norway’s Special Representative for the Ocean—a role that saw him initiate and lead the work of the High-Level Panel for a Sustainable Ocean Economy 2017-2020. He was co-chair of the Advisory Board of the UN Decade of Ocean Science for Sustainable Development and served as Norway’s Minister for Climate and the Environment—among other responsibilities—before taking up his current position at IOC/UNESCO in March 2024. 

How would you sum up where we are in terms of the ocean and the SDGs?

It is a mixed picture, but the main picture is a grim one: the ocean crisis is accelerating due to climate change, biodiversity loss and pollution. 

And this is despite the fact that a lot of good multilateral initiatives—and successes—have been recorded in recent years, at what is a very difficult time for multilateralism. We had ocean dialogue firmly incorporated into the Paris Agreement and climate talks, which wasn’t the case originally. We’ve had the global biodiversity framework with its 30x30 protection target. We have the new treaty on Biodiversity Beyond National Jurisdiction (BBNJ), which provides an international framework for protecting high-seas ecosystems. We’ve had the agreement to launch plastic negotiations. And although the most recent negotiation stalled, it is very significant to have an agreement to pursue such a global pact. So there is a lot of progress, which sets the stage for better stories to tell in the future.

Nonetheless, we are seeing a deterioration in the ocean environment, which affects the land economy as well.

Why are we not closer to where we’d like to be in terms of the SDGs?

First of all, a number of these normative multilateral agreements require some time to be implemented. BBNJ ratifications are picking up, for example, but the treaty is still not in force.

When it comes to other actions, two things are very important. One is finance: among the 17 SDGs, SDG 14 is the least financed and the least invested in. 

There are different ways of looking at this, and it’s quite clear that the ocean economy is growing—faster than the land economy in fact—but there is not enough investment from governments or the private sector in ocean R&D and innovation. 

That leads me to the second point. We know a lot about the ocean crisis and the ocean economy, but there’s still a lot we don’t know. 

Take ocean seabed mapping, which is something we’re a part of: just 26% of the global sea floor has been mapped. If you look at the IOC/UNESCO Ocean Biodiversity Information System (OBIS), it has identified and describes about a quarter of a million species—but we estimate that there are about a million species. So we’re a quarter of the way to total knowledge.

What can be done to accelerate information gathering?

Something I’d love to get across in this interview is that we have a lot of private actors sitting on vast amounts of ocean data.

I mentioned that we are at 26% in the effort to map the global sea floor. If we could get all private companies that possess data to actually share what they have about the sea floor, estimates are that we would immediately get to around 45%. And much of that can be shared without compromising financial interests or security concerns. 

There is the need both to observe and gather more data, and a need to share more data. In OBIS—with the quarter of a million species reported—just 3% of the data comes from private-sector actors. And half of that is from one country, which happens to be Norway, my own country, and that is simply because the oil and gas industry has been obliged to share data. The UK, which has similar frameworks, adds a lot of that remaining half of private-sector biodiversity information. These examples are quite telling about what regulatory frameworks can achieve.

It is also important to acknowledge that even the knowledge we do have is shifting because of climate change. Ecosystems are changing at a rapid pace.

Can you share any examples of how this is happening today?

I’m Norwegian and my family history is in cod fisheries, which has been the backbone of the coastal and land economy in Norway for centuries. 

Now, because of climate change, the Arctic cod is being pushed farther north and will probably eventually disappear because of warming waters. The Atlantic cod will take over. Atlantic cod is bigger, so the conventional industry thinking has been, “Well, it’s sad that the Arctic cod is disappearing, but there's going to be more biomass, so it’s ok.”

Four years ago, marine biologists discovered something they hadn't thought of: with warming oceans, there’s more precipitation, harder and more extreme rainfall. With that, more soil enters the ocean and it darkens. A darker ocean means dying plankton—which is at the bottom of the food chain for cod. It is unclear what this will mean in the long term. 

How easy is it to come up with a time frame for an example like that?

I don't think it is possible to predict. And it’s not the only thing. There’s acidification as well, which is bad for shellfish. Shellfish is also part of the cod food chain—there are many dynamics at play here.

The major, fundamental message is unpredictability. We really need to continuously monitor and continuously observe what is happening in the ocean. And the world needs to invest much more in ocean observations, both to map and better understand the ocean—and to keep track of the changes that are happening. 

We are currently investing far too little in ocean observation. It has been seen as a domain for oceanographers, with their devices out at sea. What we need is to look at ocean observation as critical infrastructure for society—because it is about disaster preparedness.

You can detect emerging marine heatwaves that are going to strike land several months down the road, for example, and that can be very helpful for preparedness authorities and agencies in predicting extreme weather events.

Ocean prediction benefits the insurance industry, it benefits property and tourism. Essentially, all coastal industries depend on ocean observation. 

Then of course there is marine-based industry, shipping, the siting of offshore wind farms, aquaculture, the siting of marine protected areas and the ongoing monitoring of those areas—all these things require ocean observation. 

If you are to protect 30% of the seas nationally, and of the high seas, you need to know where the biodiversity exists in order to protect significant areas. 

In fact, UNESCO has just completed a pilot programme that used revolutionary eDNA sampling to quickly and affordably identify species in marine World Heritage Sites across 19 countries. This new method has achieved in months what previously would have taken years, and for a fraction of the cost. If we can eventually roll this out to the 18,000+ marine protected areas across the globe, it will be a real game-changer in terms of monitoring and protecting marine biodiversity.

The IOC/UNESCO State of the Ocean Report 2024 does a lot to point to the links between SDG 14 and the other SDGs. Is the conversation becoming more holistic?

The conversation has traditionally been marked by the ocean being a “different place”, and that’s still very much the case. If I go to ocean events, it tends to be very much the same community.

It is a challenge that we don’t have living history: people don't live in the ocean. You will not have a grandma telling you what nature used to be like here. There are no politicians, no voters, no pressure groups, no journalists living in the ocean. So the ocean is a bit apart. And that is, of course, why we need observation. Only science and observation can tell us what’s going on in the ocean.

But understanding is increasing. We are trying to advocate that what happens in the ocean doesn’t stay in the ocean. The extreme weather events that we’re seeing in the UK or in Spain or on the East Coast of the US come from, to a large extent, a warming ocean. 

What are the implications of missing the 2030 targets? Do they just get tweaked and moved further down the line?

That is a very big discussion in UN circles at the moment, and we won’t have white smoke coming out for a while on that one, I think. 

It is very unlikely that we will reach 2030 and pat ourselves on the backs and be happy, because we are lagging behind

Some of the frameworks that I’ve talked about are setting the stage for getting us there—not least on the 30% protection target. But it is a tall order to get there by 2030. Still, SDG 14 has played a role in the mobilisation [we’ve seen] to reach such concrete agreements.

Within SDG14, are there any targets that are performing better?

It’s hard to say which targets are most likely to be met. There’s a lag in keeping track and there are changes in the general political and societal environment around climate action that we’ve seen in the last couple of years—changes that are not conducive to progress.

What’s the key message you’d like to deliver at this halfway point to 2030?

We need more sound investment in the ocean—from both public and private money. But that investment needs to be knowledge-based and knowledge-driven. It might seem like a bit of a chicken-and-egg situation but you don’t always need to wait for new knowledge: there is a lot that we do know.

Views or opinions expressed are those of the author and any individuals cited, and do not necessarily reflect those of Economist Enterprise or any other member of The Economist Group.