
Rising sea levels were front and centre as the 79th UN General Assembly (UNGA) kicked off in New York in September. A high-level meeting on the existential threat posed by the 15cm to 30cm average sea-level rise expected by 2050 sat alongside a discussion on anti-microbial resistance and another on the elimination of nuclear weapons. The event was also used to drive ratification of the Biodiversity Beyond National Jurisdiction (BBNJ) Agreement, also known as the high-seas treaty. That brought in ten new signatories, including India, while the treaty was ratified by five new states, bringing the total to 13 ratifications, with 47 to go before it can move forward.
This is the first time the risks associated with rising sea levels have been so high on the UN agenda, notes Mr Tumasie Blair, deputy permanent representative of Antigua and Barbuda to the UN, who describes this as indicative of the increased attention on ocean issues. While Mr Blair says, “The feeling coming out of UNGA79 was a lot more hopeful than we had envisioned,” he adds that, for him, much of the drive behind this ocean focus is down to the “forcefulness coming out of SIDS’ leaders”. Gaston Browne, prime minister of Antigua and Barbuda, himself gave an impassioned speech at UNGA79—with a big push on climate finance.
Funding and compensation
This is a theme that, like ocean issues more generally, is moving up the agenda within the UN. For members like Antigua and Barbuda, climate finance—and compensation—is an issue “near to our hearts”, says Mr Blair, speaking not only as a representative of a country highly vulnerable to extreme weather and rising seas including Barbuda, an island that had to be completely evacuated and that is still rebuilding following the devastation caused by Hurricane Irma in 2021, but also as the custodian country of the next 10-year agenda for small-island developing states (SIDS).
Talking about the loss and damage fund agreed at COP28, Mr Blair stresses that this must not only be operational, but “must provide the type of funding stream that would allow us, as vulnerable countries, to access the type of climate finance that is needed”. He points to the pace at which funding is released from the Green Climate Fund as an example of today’s slow reality, with often years passing between an application and the issuance of funds.
“If you have a country like Antigua and Barbuda, where a storm wipes out 100% of our GDP within a few hours, and we can’t access that international support, it means that something is fundamentally wrong with the system,” he points out. Funding is expected to be a key focus at COP29, which is taking place from November 11th to 22nd 2024, in Baku, Azerbaijan.
Stan Smith, ambassador and permanent representative of the permanent mission of the Bahamas to the UN, also stresses the need for a radical shift in the way climate finance works. “Fundamentally, the change that has to be made is to a new climate economics,” he says. "What we have at the moment is a market economics that is informing how we deal with challenges that are beyond the market.”
He also stresses the urgency with which this change is needed, pointing out that there is already general consensus that the current system needs to be overhauled. This is not about making the argument for change, but about putting that change into practice. “The space we’re in is beyond making a moral argument about this,” says Mr Smith. “It has to be about how to keep communities productive, how to allow communities to keep the integrity of their identity, creating an economics that is framed by the vulnerability of the global supply chain, by consumption behaviour.”
Going under the shell
For Mr Smith, the time for waiting for the G20 and other large, developed nations—collectively responsible for the bulk of greenhouse-gas emissions—has passed. “It would be an errant exercise to wait for big states to lead in making material contributions and changes for resilient sustainability against climate change,” he says. “Decades are lost while the damage and impact worsens. The dynamics are that we must find ways to achieve safeguards while the system as an overarching bureaucracy does not work.”
This is something that the private sector is also recognising, he adds, describing private interests as “going under the shell” of the UN. Those attending the UNGA’s high-level week increasingly appreciate the space for the private-sector and bilateral meetings that happen on the margins, he explains—“more so than [for] the value propositions and the pronouncements that are being made by states”.
Mr Smith talks of a growing initiative “intended to draw small and developing states together” within a network of family-office initiatives on important country development and planetary priorities. “The public, purpose-driven private sector has realised new potential; and the vacuum created between international organisation bureaucracy and states’ lack of capacity has given it an opportunity with its more informed focus and aggregated capacities. Equal to the UN’s work to eliminate conflict, the success of programmes like this would be the most positive development emerging from the start of the 79th Session of the UN General Assembly,” he says.
Header image: Unsplash