Harnessing wave energy along with offshore wind

There is potential not just to expand energy harvested from the ocean, but to make it cheaper too.

Jonathan Hodges
Jonathan Hodges
Wave Energy Scotland (WES)

25 Jul 2023

Header image

Offshore wind is central to the UK’s decarbonisation plans, with nearly 14 gigawatts (GW) of turbines already generating clean, renewable electricity, and another 70GW in the pipeline. But there is potential not just to expand energy harvested from the ocean, but to make it cheaper too. 

Sharing ocean space—as well as infrastructure, services and the supply chain—with wave-energy technologies could generate substantial savings, both for offshore wind, which could see cost reductions of 7%, and for wave energy, whose cost could drop by 40%. 

These savings could drive further investment in another 6GW of capacity in wave energy in UK waters by 2050, say researchers at the University of Edinburgh, adding over £20bn to the UK economy through domestic and export sales, as well as significantly reducing the additional energy storage capacity required and costs of balancing the UK grid.

On a good day, the UK’s wind farms can provide more than 50% of the country’s electricity demand. Future wind farms are expected to move further offshore, into deeper, higher-energy waters. This is the case with The Crown Estate Scotland’s 2022 leasing round, ScotWind, in which developers paid over £750m to secure seabed option agreements on 20 sites. The water depth at these sites necessitates a switch from seabed-fixed wind turbines to floating devices—14 of the 20 options include floating wind—and this requires a whole new supply chain for floating platforms. 

But the fact that some of these floating-wind sites are located off the north-west coast of Scotland brings another opportunity. These are not just windy seas—they are home to some of the most powerful waves on the planet. When winds fall slack, waves generated by distant storms continue to arrive on Europe’s shores, and researchers say this makes wave energy an ideal complement to offshore wind to meet energy demand.

Overcoming challenges with wave energy

Waves represent a very dense renewable-energy resource, with many areas, including Scotland’s Western Isles and Orkney, receiving vast amounts of power from the North Atlantic ocean. Indeed, with the right technologies and supporting energy system, wave energy could contribute up to 10% of the UK’s electricity demand by 2050. Engineers have worked for decades to harness this source, but the key challenge has been the substantial variation in forces experienced by these machines between normal and stormy conditions—a differential of up to 100 times. This variation makes it difficult to build a device strong enough to survive storms without being too expensive.

But technology has recently taken huge steps forward, such as the large-scale devices from the Wave Energy Scotland programme which were demonstrated at the European Marine Energy Centre in Orkney. There is also interest from national governments and the European Commission to further develop technology, supply chains and the commercialisation pathway. Technology developers are now focusing on achieving the balance of performance, reliability and cost that will enable the power of the Atlantic waves finally to become part of our electricity generation portfolio.

Scaling up wave energy with offshore wind

wave energy there are two clear pathways to scale-up in partnership with floating wind. The first is using the space between the floating wind turbines. With ever-increasing turbine rotor diameters comes a need for greater distance between wind turbines, to avoid losses in the energy yield. The distance between 15MW turbines can be over a kilometre, leaving valuable space within the farm. This space can be used by wave-energy devices, which can share other infrastructure such as electrical cables and substations as well as operation and maintenance services—resulting in cost savings to both wind and wave systems.

The second pathway also introduces opportunities in supply-chain sharing. The giant 90-100m-wide floating substructures required to support large offshore wind turbines could be adapted to provide a versatile platform—one that can support either wind-turbine or multiple wave-energy converters. The multi-absorber wave platforms themselves could also occupy space in the wind farm, meaning wind and wave could share the new platform supply chain, leading to cost savings and less variability in power generation. Research has shown that the versatile-platform (wind or wave) solution would deliver most of the savings that could be achieved by a fully hybrid (wind and wave) platform, without the currently unacceptable risks.

This integration could bring opportunities which are enticing for governments and the wind industry alike, including reduced energy costs, a more balanced electricity grid, increased local content in offshore-wind projects and, not least, the route to that long sought-after outcome: a commercial wave-energy industry.

Devices for capturing the powerful waves of the North Atlantic are now performing at a large scale, with the energetic waters of Orkney having provided an appropriately testing stage. As wind farms move further offshore into deeper water with larger waves, now is the time to add a foil to floating wind’s leading act.

Artist’s impression of megawatt-scale Mocean Energy wave devices Artist’s impression of megawatt-scale Mocean Energy wave devices co-located with floating wind turbines [Mocean Energy - © Matt Brown Productions]
Courtesy of AWS Ocean EnergyArtist’s impression of an AWS Ocean Energy multi-absorber platform concept, based on floating wind substructure

Views or opinions expressed are the individuals and do not necessarily reflect those of Economist Enterprise or any other member of The Economist Group