Food swap: the planet needs to curb its appetite for meat

Modest changes in diet could go some way to reducing greenhouse-gas emissions, offering a practical approach to tackling climate change

24 Jun 2024

Food swap:  the planet needs to curb its appetite for meat

Eating well for the planet doesn’t have to be confined to chickpeas and almond milk—even if plant-based diets have far less of an environmental toll than animal-based ones. For those who find going fully plant-based unpalatable, even a low-meat diet makes a significant difference. 

Food systems are responsible for roughly 30% of human-caused emissions globally. Even if we eliminate all emissions belched by burning fossil fuels, those emitted from food alone would still prevent the world from limiting warming to 1.5℃, the enshrined goal set by the Paris Agreement, according to a study published by Science.

But it is the environmental cost of meat consumption that is staggering. Livestock farming is responsible for roughly 14.5% of global greenhouse-gas emissions, despite providing a fraction of the world’s calories and protein. Animal H demands vast quantities of water, land and feed, generating significant methane emissions—a greenhouse gas far more potent than carbon dioxide. 

The EAT-Lancet Commission—a panel of distinguished nutrition, agriculture and climate experts—advises no more than 26kg of meat per person per year for planetary and human health. Most of the world exceeds this recommendation; Americans consume nearly five times it. A major study finds a drastic reduction in meat-eating, particularly in rich countries, “essential” to avoid climate breakdown. 

Food swap gifSources: Food systems are responsible for a third of global anthropogenic GHG emissions. Nature Food 2, 198–209 (2021), Feeding climate and biodiversity goals with novel plant-based meat and milk alternatives. Nature Communications 14, 5316 (2023)

Small dietary changes can have a profound cumulative effect, says Anna H. Grummon, assistant professor of paediatrics and health policy at Stanford University. Her 2023 study in Nature Food examined the impact of simple dietary substitutions among over 7,700 Americans. The largest reductions in emissions were seen in mixed dishes like burritos and pastas, substituting lower-impact proteins for beef.

“Our paper focused on small dietary swaps because these changes may be simpler and more achievable for some than making more radical dietary changes,” says Ms Grummon. 

Better plant-based products and lower prices, resulting from improved technology and scale, have allowed flexitarianism—eating less meat rather than refraining from it entirely—to flourish. Still, taking meat off the menu is politically controversial, even if it is a sure way to reduce the impact on the planet. In 2021, US President Joe Biden was nicknamed the “Hamburglar” due to false speculation that he would limit red meat consumption to reduce emissions. 

Pushback against politicians limiting our consumption of carbon-intensive meat is matched by an inertia in consumer habits. Aside from making some dietary swaps to cut emissions, people could stop wasting so much food through simple measures like meal planning, proper storage and mindful consumption. There is a glaring lack of effort at a national level to stem food waste—only 22 of the 78 countries in Economist Enterprise’s Food Sustainability Index (FSI) have dedicated food-waste strategies. In low-income countries, food loss and waste is exacerbated by infrastructure gaps and patchy electricity, making it difficult to store and transport food without spoiling, according to the research. 

Other policies could help nudge consumers to make small substitutions, significantly reducing our dietary carbon footprint. Policymakers could make healthier, more sustainable foods available through institutional procurement policies reaching schools, government buildings and hospitals. Prominent food labels highlighting the environmental and health impacts of what we eat would provide greater transparency and empower the buyer, says Ms Grummon. And through pricing policies like taxes and subsidies, she says, better choices would also become the more affordable ones. 

The Food Imperative header

The Food Imperative

The Food ImperativeThe Food Imperative is Economist Enterprise’s commitment to transform our global food systems for the future. Designed to arm decision-makers with the data, insights and tools they need to develop more sustainable and secure solutions, The Food Imperative will map and unpack best-practice policies, untangle agro-industrial complexities and pressure-test approaches that promise positive, inclusive economic outcomes.

Learn more

Header image: Unsplash