Finding cultures of ocean innovation
While the US has a large number of ocean startup support organisations, countries like Iceland and Norway demonstrate remarkable density per capita, indicating a deep-rooted and vibrant ocean-entrepreneur ecosystem - writes David Hume, founder and editor-in-chief of The Liquid Grid
7 Jun 2024

Startup incubators, accelerators, innovation hubs and competitions represent a relatively new approach to fostering young businesses. Many of these support organisations offer entrepreneurs a blend of mentorship, funding and networking opportunities that were not traditionally available in one package. While there are generalist support organisations, there are also many supporting specific sectors like climate tech, agriculture, pharmaceuticals and even ocean technology. The concept of a support organisation is an innovation itself, and the idea has spread widely.
The diffusion of ocean start-up support organisations depends in part on innovation culture across geographical regions. Those with a strong culture of innovation and entrepreneurship are more likely to found support organisations. Naturally, those regions with a strong culture of ocean tech innovation are more likely to grow ocean-specific support organisations.
Consider the chart below which shows the number of ocean support organisations founded within the Asia Pacific (APAC); Europe, Middle East and Africa (EMEA); and North America (NAM) regions.
At first glance, it seems like America has more support organisations than Asia and Europe combined. But at this level of granularity it doesn’t tell us much about the culture of ocean innovation within these regions.
A region with a strong culture of ocean innovation is one that has a large number of ocean-entrepreneur support organisations relative to its population size. This would imply a high concentration of innovators seeking support within a particular area served by the support organisation. In the chart below we show the number of support organisations relative to the population of the countries where they are headquartered.
While the United States has the greatest number of ecosystem organisations, on a per capita basis it is dwarfed by Iceland, Norway, Singapore and Finland. With so many ocean start-up support organisations for their population, it suggests that there are many entrepreneurs in that region seeking their services. Monaco, with its small population and single ocean-support organisation appears on the chart as an outlier.
On a per capita basis, the median number of ocean startup support organisations within a country is approximately one per five million people. Countries exceeding this ratio can be considered to have a strong culture of ocean innovation. For example, Norway is almost 12 times that of the global median, and Iceland is even larger.
The US is a large place, and some states have populations greater than countries. Moreover, not all US states have an interest in ocean innovation. Arkansas or North Dakota are unlikely to ever have a culture of ocean innovation for example. Disaggregating the US into the relevant states that have support organisations is shown in the chart below.
At this level of granularity, it is evident that some US states have strong cultures of ocean innovation rivalling countries. Interestingly, California with its rich culture of entrepreneurship is relatively low in this ranking on a per capita basis, but high in absolute number. This is likely due to its large population. Rhode Island, with a population of approximately one million has a single support organisation, the same as Texas, which has a population 30 times as large.
Norway and Massachusetts are the most notable stand-outs in this chart on both absolute and per capita basis. This is unsurprising as these areas both have rich maritime heritages. Jonas Skattum Svegaarden, CEO of the Norwegian based Katapult Ocean, the world’s most active ocean-impact venture fund, remarks: “Norway has a long history and wealth of ocean industries and there has been a focus on building strong ocean innovation support organisations. This is driven not only from the governmental and scientific side, but also by the corporations and private markets.”
Of course, cultures of ocean innovation are not just about the number of support organisations that exist within the region. In our increasingly globalised economy geographical boundaries become less of a constraint. Quality of support, proximity to test facilities and pro-business regulations can also affect regional differences. But ocean entrepreneurs take heed—regions with high concentrations of ocean-support organisations suggest a vibrant ecosystem where you’re more likely to find collaborators and funding.
The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) is trying to help grow these existing regions of ocean innovation, and seed new ones. Zack Baize, a Program Manager at NOAA overseeing the Ocean-based Climate Resilience Accelerators program noted,
“As the ocean economy continues to rapidly grow and evolve, NOAA recognizes the critical role that entrepreneurs and innovators from the private sector can play in the development and delivery of new technologies and services to meet emerging needs. NOAA’s National Ocean Service (NOS) is committed to collaborative partnerships, like the Ocean-based Climate Resilience Accelerators (OCRA) program, that bring together government, academia, and private sector partners to identify these needs and work together towards solutions that benefit both the marine environment and the US economy."

Norway has a long history and wealth of ocean industries and there has been a focus on building strong ocean innovation support organisations. This is driven not only from the governmental and scientific side, but also by the corporations and private markets.
The innovation of specialised organisations supporting ocean-tech entrepreneurs has diffused globally. Tracking the number of these organisations provides an indication of the culture of ocean innovation in specific regions. While the United States has a large number of ocean startup support organisations, countries like Iceland and Norway demonstrate remarkable density per capita, indicating a deep-rooted and vibrant ocean-entrepreneur ecosystem. Strong ocean cultures are appealing for startups, especially for those that need to build their human and social capital.
Views or opinions expressed are those of the author and any individuals cited, and do not necessarily reflect those of Economist Enterprise or any other member of The Economist Group.
Header image: Unsplash