Houston, we have a problem

John A. Cook, CIM
Senior Vice President, Portfolio Manager, Mackenzie Greenchip Team
On January 10th, NASA scientists confirmed that 2024 was the hottest year since global temperature record keeping began in 1880. For those who believe climate change to be mostly related to anthropogenic greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, reversing the global warming trend appears an extremely difficult challenge. It will require massive construction of energy infrastructure (mostly for renewable energy), large-scale efficiency upgrades for industrial facilities, and a major expansion of mining and processing of green metals and materials. These activities come at great financial cost, and entail a footprint that intuitively no one wants. But there is a real need to accelerate economic activity targeted at advancing the energy transition, just as incoming populist governments repeal “carrot and stick” policies that support such endeavours. The greatest challenge to mobilising the capital required, however, is likely to exist inside capital markets themselves.
Despite a historic US$2trn investment in clean energy in 2024, this is only half of what is needed to stabilise global emissions. Progress is hindered by three main forces. First, the language used to label sustainable investment strategies confuses investors and is likely to distract capital from the very solutions they may hope to back. Second, professional investing has developed a fixation on benchmarks dominated by sectors that have little to do with the energy transition. And finally, both the taxonomy and the benchmarks support growing investor aversion to capital-intensive business models.
The taxonomy for environmental investment strategies is overly complex. Labels such as “sustainable”, “climate”, “SRI” (socially responsible investing) and “ESG” (environmental, social and governance) are used interchangeably, often without clear distinctions. Only two labels are actually needed. The first of these is “energy transition” strategies, which mobilise capital towards building infrastructure and technologies today, to ensure a genuinely lower-carbon economy in the future. The second, in contrast, is “low-carbon” strategies, which allocate capital to current low-carbon sectors and risk locking in emissions at a higher level than would be the case under an energy transition approach.
Unfortunately, most strategies labelled with the terms outlined above are low-carbon strategies. These soak up most of the environmentally focused capital at the expense of true energy transition approaches.
Although there are hundreds of low-carbon indexes, investors will find fewer than ten energy transition sector indexes.
Benchmarks do little to address label obfuscation. MSCI, a major index provider, offers hundreds of “sustainability and climate solutions” indexes. Almost all of them should be categorised as “low-carbon”. For instance, the MSCI World Climate Change Index and the MSCI World ESG Leaders Index show a remarkable overlap in top constituents, sectors and country weights with the firm’s global standard benchmark, the MSCI World Index.1 It would be hard to argue that any of these indexes are designed to drive capital allocations to energy transition solutions.
Although there are hundreds of low-carbon indexes, investors will find fewer than ten energy transition sector indexes. The latter tend to be narrowly defined, like the S&P Global Clean Energy Index and the MSCI ACWI IMI Clean Energy Infrastructure Index, and cover only parts of what is needed for an energy transition.

Mackenzie Greenchip, which has managed an energy transition strategy since 2007, believes a broader global energy transition index is needed that includes energy efficiency, clean-up technologies, water, agriculture and transportation, as well as clean energy.
Although information technology, financials, consumer discretionary and healthcare dominate low-carbon portfolios, the “Greenchip universe” of around 2,000 energy transition companies is largely found in the industrial, utilities and materials sectors. Technology is also well represented, but energy transition technologies tend to be in the form of hardware (such as solar equipment or analog power management semiconductors), rather than digital technologies. Unsurprisingly, the Greenchip universe and other energy transition indexes have significant tracking errors with broader low-carbon ones.
Mackenzie Greenchip, which has managed an energy transition strategy since 2007, believes a broader energy transition index is needed.
In 2008, Russell Investments and Impax launched the FTSE Environmental Opportunities AlIn 2008, Russell Investments and Impax launched the FTSE Environmental Opportunities All-Share Index with about 450 constituents (mostly names found in the Greenchip universe). Today the index has over 1,000 constituents; over the years, names have been added that seem decidedly less relevant to the energy transition. For example, Microsoft is currently the largest constituent. Arguably, 11 of the top 20 names should not qualify as energy transition businesses, yet they account for more than 30% of the index by market capitalisation and for over 50% of its 2024 performance.2 What seemed to be a unique energy transition benchmark now looks increasingly like a low-carbon index.
Today, both the taxonomy and the indexes largely prioritise low-carbon over energy transition investment. Why? Because it suits investor preference for low-capex business models – low carbon is low capital!
Public equity markets were supposed to be a place where companies could go to raise capital to invest in and grow their businesses. From 1990 to 2023, S&P 500 dividends and buy-backs increased from 42% of capex to over 120%; they now exceed the sum of IPOs, follow-ons, debt issuance and capex. Arguably, public equity markets have become a source of rent on the economy, rather than a place to finance growth – or, indeed, the energy transition.
Climate challenges cannot be overcome unless investors are willing to re-embrace capex, supported by clearer language and dedicated benchmarks.
For institutional use only. This article is based on the opinion of the author based on independent research that has not been separately verified by Mackenzie Investments. This material is provided for marketing and informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice or an offer of investment products or services (or an invitation to make such an offer). Certain information contained in this document is obtained from third parties and is believed to be accurate and reliable as at the date hereof, however, it cannot be guaranteed that it is accurate or complete or current at all times. The information provided is subject to change without notice and Mackenzie Investments cannot be held liable for any loss arising from any use of or reliance on the information contained in this document. Examples related to specific securities are not intended to constitute investment advice or any form of recommendation in relation to those securities. This material contains forward-looking statements which reflect our current expectations or forecasts of future events. Forward looking statements are inherently subject to, among other things, risks, uncertainties and assumptions which could cause actual events, results, performance or prospects to differ materially from those expressed in, or implied by, these forward-looking statements. Please do not place undue reliance on forward-looking statements.

References
- 1.MSCI World Climate Change Index, December 31st 2024 : https://www.msci.com/indexes/index/726315
- 2.FTSE Environmental Opportunities Index Series, December 31st 2024: : https://www.lseg.com/en/ftse-russell/index-resources/factsheets
