Don’t buy the greenwashing – we don’t need deep-sea mining

A guest blog by Dr Dan Kammen, professor of energy at the University of California, Berkeley

Dr Dan Kammen
Dr Dan Kammen
professor of sustainability at the University of California, Berkeley

5 Feb 2024

Don’t buy the greenwashing – we don’t need deep-sea mining

It is a good day indeed when science, US job creation, bipartisan politics, economics, technological advances, Indigenous wisdom, social justice and ocean protection all align. When that happens, we had better not stay silent, but instead spring into action to capture the moment and put a stop to the hawks claiming the contrary. 

Now is that moment.

Mining companies, and most recently the Norwegian government, are threatening to open the least explored and most fragile ecosystem on the planet, and humankind’s common heritage—the deep seabed. 

The objective is most commonly to mine polymetallic nodules that the pressure of the deep ocean has deposited in some areas on the seabed floor over millions of years. The risk we face is that deep-sea mining will destroy untold species (some as yet undiscovered) on the seabed, and disturb much larger areas still through the pollution of waters with silt and mining detritus. This risk demands our attention because otherwise it is out of sight—and, its exploiters hope, out of mind, literally thousands of feet down on the dark ocean floor.

Miners are claiming this must be done in the name of the energy transition. They are wrong. 

Yes, the transition is under way. We stand on the cusp of a clean-energy revolution, where fossil-fuel (hydrocarbon) combustion is giving way to an energy sector based on metals and minerals for solar panels, wind turbines, batteries and smart, connected electrical grids that power our homes, industry and our transport needs. Remarkably, it is already the case that it is cheaper to build a new renewable-energy power plant than it is to simply operate existing fossil-fuel power plants . It is also now crystal clear that per dollar invested, there are more jobs in building this new clean-energy economy than investing in the fossil-fuel economy—often by a factor of two or three—which is a result we have been finding and reconfirming for well over a decade.

Mining companies have been lobbying the International Seabed Authority (ISA), a quasi-UN body headquartered in Kingston, Jamaica, which has been given the conflicting responsibility of stewarding our seabed while issuing licences to strip-mine the deep seabed in the high seas in Areas Beyond National Jurisdiction—which cover approximately half of our planet yet remain the most inaccessible and least explored areas on Earth. Observers have flagged a potential conflict of interest inherent in the competing demands of the ISA mandate that puts the future of the Pacific Ocean’s biodiversity-rich Clarion Clipperton Zone (CCZ), an area that stretches as wide as the continental US, at risk.

While there are some bottlenecks in mineral supplies, technologies are already moving ahead of these. We don’t need to harvest these materials and despoil the seabed, not just because of advances in battery science, but also because of the untapped potential of recycling, and the jobs and economic leadership potential that this opens for the US. 

This is good news for the health of the ocean, which has been threatened in recent years by the spectre of deep-sea mining. For example, new electric-vehicle (EV) batteries don’t need to contain the metals that mining companies want to mine in the CCZ. As highlighted in Blue Climate Initiative’s recent white paper Next Generation EV Batteries Eliminate the Need for Deep Sea Mining, these new nickel- and cobalt-free batteries, which make use instead of lithium iron phosphate, now represent nearly one-third of the global EV battery market. That market size is projected to double in the next five years. 

The remarkable success of these EV batteries and many other new chemistries coming to market, along with growing battery-recycling solutions, has eliminated the claimed need for deep-sea mining to support the growing EV market and provided an easy opportunity to avoid the environmental disaster associated with mining the deep seabed. 

This is great news on many fronts. Sales of EVs in the US passed 1 million in 2023 alone, and the Inflation Reduction Act as well as the Chips and Science Act (2022) put a premium on on-shoring materials supply chains to enable the clean-energy transition while reaping the employment benefits domestically. Leading car companies—major consumers of battery materials—are increasingly onboard with a ban on materials from conflict zones and from the deep seabed.

So it is quite simply time to act. The world needs a moratorium—or an outright ban—on deep-sea mining.

Views or opinions expressed are those of the author and any individuals cited, and do not necessarily reflect those of Economist Enterprise or any other member of The Economist Group.