Charting the course to quieter and cleaner ships and seas

A guest blog by Melanie Knight, program manager, the ECHO Program

Melanie Knight
Melanie Knight
program manager, the ECHO Program

18 Jun 2024

Charting the course to quieter and cleaner ships and seas

Off Canada’s west coast is one of the most biologically diverse coastal ecosystems in the world. Known to some as the Salish Sea, this area of the Pacific Ocean is made up of hundreds of islands and estuaries that collectively support an abundance of marine life, including more than 20 species of whales, dolphins and porpoises. Among the marine species that call this habitat home are the southern resident killer whales, an endangered orca population of immense spiritual value to the First Nations groups who have lived and harvested fish along the south-western coast of Canada for millennia. 

Today, this population of just 75 orcas face imminent threats to their survival. One of the main threats facing these whales is underwater noise—a side-effect of commercial shipping that, until recently, was not well understood. We now know that underwater noise is one of the major threats facing endangered whales globally, and has been increasing dramatically alongside the growth of commercial-shipping activity throughout our oceans—with some estimates showing that underwater noise from shipping has doubled roughly every decade.

Killer whale 1A southern resident killer whale seen breaching near English Bay in Vancouver, Canada. Photo credit: Joan Lopez

To better understand threats such as underwater noise to the southern resident killer whales, the Vancouver Fraser Port Authority—which oversees the Port of Vancouver, Canada’s largest port—launched the Enhancing Cetacean Habitat and Observation (or ECHO) Program in 2014. The program —which is composed of partners and advisers from across government, the marine transportation industry, environmental groups and indigenous communities—started by posing the following questions: what factors are contributing to increased underwater noise, and what measures can be taken to mitigate them for the benefit of endangered whales?

These questions led the program and its partners to undertake a series of research studies using underwater listening stations placed beneath busy commercial shipping lanes off Canada’s west coast, with support from JASCO Applied Sciences and the Canadian government. The data from these underwater listening stations showed that while there are various factors that affect how much underwater noise a commercial ship emits—such as its size and draft—the most effective way to reduce underwater noise from ships was by slowing down.

Melanie Knight at WOSMelanie Knight, program manager of the ECHO program, speaking at the World Ocean Summit in Lisbon, Portugal. Photo credit: Vancouver Fraser Port Authority

Based on this finding, the ECHO Program and its partners devised a radically simple approach to reducing acoustic disturbance to whales: in 2017, they began asking thousands of ship captains en route to the Port of Vancouver to slow down as their ships travelled through areas of importance to southern resident killer whales. A majority of ship operators participated, and underwater sound intensity was cut in half in key areas of the orcas’ critical habitat—earning the program international recognition for its simple but effective approach to reducing threats to whales.

But slowing down isn’t the only way that ships can reduce their underwater noise emissions. Research by the ECHO Program and its partners shows that technologies that were initially developed to increase ships' energy efficiency, such as air-lubrication systems and wind-assist technologies, can also reduce underwater noise. Additionally, certain types of propeller equipment—such as equipment that reduces cavitation and improves wake flow—can also have a noise-quieting effect.

Killer whale 2 Southern resident killer whales in Boundary Pass, a key area of the orcas’ critical habitat off the west coast of Canada. Photo credit: Olivia Murphy

These findings on the physical factors that impact ships’ noise emissions are what led the Vancouver Fraser Port Authority to become the first port authority in the world to offer incentives for quieter ships, through the EcoAction Program, which provides up to 75% off port fees for cleaner and quieter ships that call the Port of Vancouver. Since the port authority introduced incentives for quieter ships in 2017, the number of ships that have qualified for an underwater noise-related discount has nearly doubled.

The ECHO Program’s research isn’t just pushing the dial towards quieter ships at the Port of Vancouver; it’s also making a difference globally. Today, the underwater listening station that was installed beneath commercial shipping lanes off Canada’s west coast has amassed the world’s largest non-military database of underwater ship noise. This database is aiding researchers across the world in modelling and predicting underwater noise from ships, including in a study which mapped the geographical distribution of global underwater-noise emissions from ships.

Port of VancouverThe Port of Vancouver is Canada’s largest port and the third largest in North America by tonnes of cargo. Photo credit: Vancouver Fraser Port Authority

Recently, the findings unlocked by this underwater listening station were used to help shape international policy at the International Maritime Organisation, where representatives from the ECHO Program and the government of Canada provided input to the IMO’s underwater noise guidelines. These guidelines were officially revised and republished in 2023 to incorporate the most up-to-date science on how underwater noise from ships can effectively be reduced around the world.

As the dialogue continues globally about how ships can be built and retrofitted to produce fewer emissions, it is the hope of the ECHO Program that attention will be paid not just to how ships can be made cleaner, but how they can also be made quieter.

Killer whale 3 Southern resident killer whales seen in Haro Strait, off the coast of British Columbia, Canada. Photo Credit: Jeanne Hyde

Views or opinions expressed are those of the author and any individuals cited, and do not necessarily reflect those of Economist Enterprise or any other member of The Economist Group.

Header image: Unsplash