Challenges of technology transfer for blue-economy innovation

Blaine Grimes of Gulf of Maine Ventures group discusses the challenges of talent gaps, funding hurdles and technical complexities facing blue-economy innovation

Blaine Grimes
Blaine Grimes
lead for Gulf of Maine Ventures group, the entrepreneurship and innovation arm of the Gulf of Maine Research Institute (GMRI)

25 Mar 2024

Challenges of technology transfer for blue-economy innovation

Across many industries and market spaces, independent research institutes play an important role in the development of new technologies and products. Their ability to attract philanthropic and federal funding allows them to take on the risks and expenses related to early product development.

At the same time, commercialisation of these new technologies and products has long been a challenge for independent research institutions due to a host of well-understood complexities, including risk-averse scientific cultures and organisational structures that reward publishing but not entrepreneurship. Every day, important and interesting technologies fail to access the additional funding necessary to explore licensing or spin out options. Inherently interesting new technologies are developed without first considering, “Who actually wants this product?” or “What problem does this solve for my customer?” In other words, “Is my interesting idea also valuable?” Research and scientific institutions that desire to monetise staff-generated ideas require constant reminders to first ask and answer these kinds of questions.

The challenge of moving inventions out of research institutions and into the private market is especially evident in emerging sectors such as the blue economy, which face all the normal barriers of commercialisation and technology transfer amidst a literal and figurative sea of other challenges. 

In the United States, there are well-established, federally funded programmes designed to shepherd researchers through the customer-discovery and product/market-fit phases into opportunities for extended R&D and market development. Indeed, major US federal agencies seem increasingly motivated to identify and pull ocean and climate-resilience technologies out of R&D stages and into more traditional commercialisation pathways, evidenced by new calls for proposals from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, National Science Foundation, US Economic Development Administration and more. 

While the interest and incentives appear to be increasing for blue-economy innovation, monetisation is especially tricky in the blue economy, due to a lack of specialised leadership talent, inadequate access to bridge capital to move products to commercial “readiness”, and the inherent complexity of ocean-related technologies, which leads to long development timelines.

The challenge of moving inventions out of research institutions and into the private market is especially evident in emerging sectors such as the blue economy, which face all the normal barriers of commercialisation and technology transfer amidst a literal and figurative sea of other challenges.

Problem 1: Lack of talent ready to lead technically complex, longer-horizon company development

The blue-economy marketplace suffers from a lack of seasoned entrepreneurs ready to take the helm of nascent companies. While there are many emerging innovations that merit attention, the current talent pool coming out of graduate programmes or recent entrepreneurs ready for their next run seem either uninformed or uninterested in leading companies that don’t conform to the more appealing, fast pay-off software-as-a-service structures. To build a company in the marine sector, leaders must appreciate the complex operating environment and the more capital-intensive nature of product development. They must also be comfortable both in complex technical contexts that require intense attention to detail, as well as classic entrepreneurial settings that require high-level strategic vision, customer identification and sales savvy.  As a whole, this sector is struggling with a mismatch between the current generation of risk-tolerant entrepreneurial talent and that talent pool’s capacity to commit to longer-term ocean-based challenges.

Problem 2: Inadequate access to bridge capital

Independent research institutions across the country are struggling to access the bridge capital required to support research ideas that are not quite ready for commercialisation. An entire pipeline of good ideas is currently trapped within NGOs and private research institutions that lack formal internal tech-transfer capacity to pursue licensing opportunities or established business partners who can serve as offtakers of these technologies. Philanthropically funded institutions focus on securing grants that cover staff-salary support and their mission-related programmatic work rather than commercialisation. At the same time, federal funding programmes which provide stellar support for R&D and innovative technologies also prohibit these same independent research institutions from serving as the lead on funding proposals. Without established private-sector partners or the internal staff capacity to identify those partners, these research institutions are often forced to abandon viable commercialisable ideas.  

Problem 3: A complex operating environment leading to a long development and funding cycle

The complexity of the marine economy and technical difficulty of operating in salt water has led to market consolidation and vertical integration of the major industry players and their supply chains, as well as entrenched, long-standing vendor-partner agreements.  Simultaneously, the balance of the market is disaggregated, with numerous sub-scale commercial operators across all marine sectors around the globe. These factors combine to make life difficult for startup companies. Consider the major industries in which innovation might make a big impact, such as shipping/marine transport, commercial fishing, aquaculture or offshore wind. While each of these industries is striving to evolve to more sustainable operating structures and increased system efficiencies in light of emerging climate challenges and global regulatory pressures, they are ill prepared to explore innovative alternative technologies. This makes it incredibly difficult for the average entrepreneur or innovative researcher to identify entry points for customer conversations about the inherent market challenges related to deep-blue-tech solutions or to pilot test products and services that could be viable. Bottom line: the potential customer market for these innovators is bifurcated between very small operators which can not yet afford to update new technologies and large multinational corporations for which the entrepreneurs’ solutions are usually sub-scale. 

Ultimately, the difficulty of getting blue-economy innovations to their first customers leads to a disconnect in the capital stack between the early-stage grant funding and even impact investments on which many blue-economy startups survive for their first year and the current venture-investment market, which typically seeks a 5-to-10-year pay-off.  The inherently longer timescale necessary for blue economy entrepreneurs to get access to their first customers requires patient capital—something which the blue economy is sorely lacking.

Solutions:

To increase the available talent to lead blue-economy companies, we need to a) make the blue economy more appealing to entrepreneurs and investors, b) develop a system to pair up technical talent from multiple sectors, c) invite older, more experienced operators back into the market to mentor/partner with younger talent, and d) coach and encourage younger scientists and engineers who may aspire to a differentiated career path, to support risk-taking in a non-academic framework and back them up with business development, team-building and investment support. Finally, the NGOs themselves need to provide a flexible structure for “tenured” staff to bridge the gap so that they can both retain their internal status but also spend time on commercialisation activities that fall outside their primary grant-funded mandate.

To address the bridge-capital gap, one obvious solution would be for the federal agencies which fund early-stage R&D programmes to develop a mechanism to allow private research institutions to apply for funding support for ideas that have commercialisable merit. Alternatively, it may be more viable for a group of private research institutions to band together as partners with an independent private R&D platform developed to warehouse commercialisable technology. 

Finally, the complexity of operating in the marine environment requires open dialogue between researchers and industry members, whose complementary perspectives can address shared challenges and spur innovation. Company-building blue-economy accelerators will play a key role, due to their embedded deep-content knowledge, scientific capacity to assess technical solutions and staff experts with explicit industry access. This kind of programme can provide industry partners and entrepreneurs with a “win-win” framework that gives both access to industry leadership for ideation and concept validation, as well as a reasonable access point for corporations and their innovation teams to see emerging technologies before they hit the market.

the complexity of operating in the marine environment requires open dialogue between researchers and industry members...

Views or opinions expressed are those of the author and any individuals cited, and do not necessarily reflect those of Economist Enterprise or any other member of The Economist Group.

Header image: Pexels