Can climate and nature goals be achieved without environmental markets?

Increasingly, countries are putting a value on carbon and biodiversity, but they must develop scalable schemes

30 May 2025

Can climate and nature goals be achieved without environmental markets?

The saying "Money makes the world go around" has rarely seemed so relevant. From government initiatives to business investments, climate action—or inaction—will define the 2020s, with major deadlines arriving for both the Paris climate agreement and the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework by the end of the decade. Climate finance is an increasingly important pathway to avert the irreversible damage that missed targets would wreak. 

Environmental markets—mechanisms that attach monetary value to carbon sequestration and ecosystem services—are emerging as powerful tools. Early carbon credit systems drew criticism for allowing companies to pay to pollute, with American philosopher Michael J. Sandel famously equating such arrangements to "letting people pay to litter".[1] But today's frameworks are, arguably, more credible and better regulated. Carbon pricing instruments such as the EU's Emissions Trading System (ETS) charge emitters to encourage investment in cleaner technologies. As of 2024, 49 countries have implemented such measures, with a further 23 planning to do so.[2] The EU reports that the ETS has cut emissions from European power and industry plants by about 47% since 2005.[3] Scaled globally, these mechanisms could turn climate ambition into action, channelling finance to restore biodiversity and unlock broad social benefits. The question is not simply whether financial markets will stem climate change, but whether they can do so quickly enough to matter.

The distance to travel

Severe heatwaves across Europe and destructive floods in South Asia last year highlighted the need for financial flows that match the scale of the task ahead. "Environmental markets are critical," says Matthew Bell, EY’s Global Climate Change and Sustainability Services Leader. "There is currently limited incentive for organisations to artificially build in a cost of carbon, water and biodiversity loss when they're considering the profitability of their products and services."

These markets began as voluntary initiatives that offered businesses a way to demonstrate climate leadership and fund nature-based solutions. However, fragmented standards and credibility concerns have limited their impact. Kasia Klaczynska Lewis, a partner at EY and an expert in sustainability law, believes that focusing on integrity will expand their reach.

Thumbnail card for audio Photo Kasia Klaczynska Lewis Climate Policy Leader, EY

Cost is also a factor. EY analysis shows that businesses using high-integrity carbon credits alongside internal abatement can reduce decarbonisation costs for businesses by 45-65%. [4] Beyond the global north, biodiversity-rich yet economically poor countries—often home to the planet's most intact ecosystems—are able to monetise their conservation efforts through these mechanisms. "The forests they can protect, preserve and expand can become an asset like gold. They can commoditise and sell the emission removals that the forest represents," explains Ms Klaczynska Lewis. According to the World Bank, 36% of the world's remaining intact forests are managed by indigenous peoples and local communities.[5] Even if they are imperfect, environmental markets can uniquely bridge climate finance, cultural resilience and equitable development.

Biologist on a modern farm

Towards standardisation

Despite their increasing coverage, current structures have a long way to go to support climate goals. The difficulty lies in building high-integrity markets that balance scale with credibility. Advances in standards, oversight, reporting and verification will accelerate improvements in both of these aspects. Progress at the UN climate summit in Baku last year was significant. A new protocol under Article 6.2 of the Paris agreement established a governance architecture for international carbon trading, with provisions to prevent accounting duplications and market distortions. "Countries can elect to implement Article 6.2, meaning they have a lot of control over what types of projects can be pursued and how they are pursued," Ms Klaczynska Lewis points out. These provisions incorporate vital safeguards for indigenous populations while providing a pathway for nations to achieve their nationally determined contributions.

For environmental markets to scale meaningfully, the transition from voluntary to regulated frameworks needs to harmonise across jurisdictions. "The standardisation challenge permeates every aspect of carbon credit or offset projects," says Ms Klaczynska Lewis. "From legal structures to taxation mechanisms, to emissions monitoring, reporting and verification protocols." Rather than seeking to simplify the intrinsic complexity of environmental markets, regulatory systems must accommodate it, she warns.

"My response is to look at it as a grassroots harmonisation movement, where institutions and governments can learn from each other, can build a joint understanding of different policy design options and share best practices," explains Ms Klaczynska Lewis. Some policy innovations are meeting the challenge head-on. The EU’s Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) is shifting global trade dynamics by embedding carbon pricing into cross-border commerce. The mechanism enacts enforcement measures, such as financial penalties, to ensure corporate compliance and prevent market misuse.[6]

Thumbnail card for audio Photo Dr Matthew Bell Global Climate Change and Sustainability Services Leader, EY

As environmental markets evolve to address complex challenges such as climate-driven biodiversity loss, balancing innovation and regulation will become even more important. "Climate change is one of the largest contributing factors to biodiversity loss globally, and will be over the next decade," says Dr Bell, adding that we must see both national investment from countries in their natural capital and an increase in private funding to scale these markets with confidence. Integrating biodiversity credits with carbon credits could have profound effects. "By asking what nature co-benefits are delivered by a particular carbon offset project, we can lay the foundation for a biodiversity market that is emerging from—and beginning to stand apart from—the carbon market," Ms Klaczynska Lewis explains.

From market debate to market design

With less than five years left to hit critical climate and biodiversity targets, the window for incremental change has closed. Environmental markets, when designed with transparency, regulation and equity, offer a mechanism to mobilise the finance underpinning climate, nature and development goals. The transition from voluntary to regulated systems is a complex process. Yet as Dr Bell observes, early movers among nations and businesses will fare better in a carbon-constrained world, gaining market access, stakeholder trust and operational resilience. The answer is practical: environmental markets must scale rapidly, but with sufficient credibility and equity to deliver benefits and create confidence.