
A nursery for hatchlings; a calm microhabitat in which to hide or forage for food; and a natural coastal defence and a role in carbon sequestering. Research increasingly points to the benefits offered by kelp and other microalgae, including the role it plays in biodiversity. Around the world, however, these marine forests are being replaced by urchin barrens.
Almost 400km above the Arctic Circle in Tromso, Northern Norway, Dagny-Elise Anastassiou is part of a team looking for solutions. She talks about the “multi-textured, 3D” nature of established kelp forests, where you can hear as well as see the difference. “An ecosystem that has high diversity is really noisy. When you go over an urchin barren there is a loss of biodiversity—and a loss of sound as well,” explains the chief impact officer at Ava Ocean—a scallop specialist leading the Ocean Green consortium.
The landmark Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework, agreed in December 2022, set out goals and targets for 2030 and 2050, including the conservation of 30% of land, sea and inland waters, 30% restoration of degraded ecosystems, halving the introduction of invasive species and closing the $700bn per year biodiversity gap. Almost halfway to that first milestone, the UN says “current negative trends” in biodiversity and ecosystems undermine progress towards 80% of the targets across a number of its Sustainable Development Goals.

Biodiversity loss affects not just ecosystems but human health, livelihoods and quality of life.
In Norway, where some 80% of kelp forests have been lost to overfishing and ocean changes in the last 50 years, the Ocean Green project is seeking a holistic approach through “restorative harvesting” that combines urchin fishery with product development, citizen science and the local community.
Ava Ocean’s key role is in adapting the technology it uses to fish for scallops: a harvester guided by multiple cameras and sensors, which hovers above the seabed before using a precision water-flow system to lift its target—a far cry from the way urchins are typically harvested today, with divers taking hammers to rocks to prise the creatures off.
What’s your reference point?
Ocean Green is in its very early days and Ms Anastassiou points to challenges before you even enter the water. Working out what you want to achieve is one place to start. “Deciding what your reference point is for any comparison of biodiversity and species richness is very difficult, because who decides what was a healthy level?”
A “return” to previous levels might not be possible anyway. “Even if the large predators come back, with the rate of change that’s happening in the ocean, you can’t really aim to get back to that ‘original’ spot because it’s a completely different environment,” she notes.
Then there’s funding. With an initial NKr 47m in funding for three years from the Norwegian government’s Green Platform, which finances green-transition projects, Ms Anastassiou also talks about how vital it is that Ocean Green becomes economically viable.
“Many restoration or conservation projects last as long as your funding, but we want this project to stay financially viable after the initial three years,” she explains. “We need a commercial product— we need multiple products to fund this in the future.” Researchers on the project are already looking at commercialising urchin exoskeletons in feed, for example, or extracting specific enzymes— CAZymes—for bio-stimulants, cosmetics and pharmaceuticals.
To make money from products though, you need scale. Anastassiou points out that where most restoration products are focused on a few square metres, Ocean Green is talking about 1,000 square kilometres.
If successful, this is also a technology that could be expanded elsewhere and potentially be adapted to other species too. “The urchin-kelp dilemma exists in all corners of the planet from Tasmania to Japan to California to Iceland. It’s everywhere and there doesn’t seem to be a solution to tackle the problem on a large scale yet,” says Ms Anastassiou. “The technology to harvest urchins—and to build products from that—can eventually fund more restoration beyond just Norway.”
The biodiversity horsemen
The urchins targeted by Ms Anastassiou and her team are a problem but they are also native to the waters they live in and the idea is not to eradicate them completely but to help nature find a balance again. Invasive, alien species are a different kettle of fish.
Dr Evangelina Schwindt, of the National Research Council of Argentina, serves as alien-species-assessment co-ordinating lead author at the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services (IPBES)—which places invasive species among the top-five drivers of global biodiversity loss alongside changes in land and sea use, the over-exploitation of natural resources, climate change and pollution.
Inger Andersen, executive director at the United Nations Environment Programme, described these threats as the “five horsemen of the biodiversity apocalypse that is riding down harder and faster upon the world”. In an IPBES thematic assessment of alien species, published earlier this year and designed as a guide to policymakers, she noted that, of these challenges, the invasive-species problem is where the big knowledge gaps remain.
Dr Schwindt points to the added layer of difficulty when it comes to the oceans. ‘‘Marine ecosystems are really difficult to study,” she says. “It is logistically difficult and it is expensive because you are usually working under water” and, realistically, it is almost impossible to adequately monitor either open waters or coastlines.
She says there are few examples of successfully tackling invasive species in the water and that prevention is the real big hope, with countries increasingly acknowledging how important it is to work together on the issue.
“Once these species are introduced and established, there’s almost nothing you can do, because there’s no containment in the way there is with terrestrial species: a single crab can have millions of larvae, all moved by ocean currents.”
To date, more than 37,000 established alien species, including more than 3,500 with documented impacts, have been recorded worldwide. IPBES describes new invasive species as being “introduced globally at an unprecedented rate”, with approximately 200 new alien species recorded every year.
Rules and regulations—and opportunity
Dr Schwindt points to the shipping industry as a big player in preventing the spread of invasive marine species. “To predict a new invasion is difficult, but it’s highly related to propagule pressure: the more ships that go to one place, the greater chance you have for new introductions,” she says, adding that “recreational vessels don’t have the same regulations as commercial vessels and so those are really difficult to manage”.
In 2023 the International Maritime Organisation (IMO) published new guidelines on hull maintenance to reduce the movement of alien species. It also agreed international, legally binding rules on ballast water in 2004—which came into force in 2017—requiring that ships eliminate aquatic organisms and pathogens before the water is released in a new location. IPBES says the global efficacy of those rules cannot be assessed yet, but there “is evidence that it has reduced invasive alien species introductions in the Great Lakes of North America”, where one new alien species was discovered every seven months between 1959 and 2006—including the zebra mussel, which has been implicated in the transfer of botulinum toxin to higher trophic levels. Since the ballast-water regulations came into play, IPBES says there has been “an abrupt shift (an 85% decline) in the number of newly established alien species”.
Back in Norway, Ms Anastassiou says that while the Ocean Green team is working on long-term solutions to the urchin problem, they hope their intervention can be short-term.
And the signs are already positive. “Within a few months, the forest in the small area where we were in Tromso started to grow back. You don’t need to worry about seeding it or planting new kelp forests—you just need to give it the opportunity.”
Header image: Unsplash